Korva is a scroll of the internet’s best ideas.
Selling a loan sells the lawsuit
Claims travel with the loan
Syndicated loans trade on standardized forms, and a buyer receives every right, claim, and cause of action the seller held. Unlike in the bond market, that means a lender cannot sell its way out of a harm: whoever buys the loan steps into the seller's shoes, and the claim lives on. Selling would not mitigate any damage at all, and the court agreed.
A market without a tape
Serta's side argued the opposite: the left-behind lenders could have sold their roughly $700 million in loans to the market, so they could not sue for damages. The facts undercut it. Bond trades can be traced through a system called Trace, but the syndicated loan market has nothing like it, only word of mouth: calling brokers and asking who is interested, at what level, and in what size. These were third-out loans in a deeply distressed company, at risk of being pushed to fourth if anyone did another exchange, and the excluded lenders, leaders in the space with access to the best potential buyers, found no one with enough appetite.
The disqualified lender list
After the uptier, Serta and the participating lenders also created a disqualified lender list, a DQ list, that kept the most active distressed investors from buying these loans. In the syndicated loan market a borrower has some say over who its lenders are. Apollo sued after it contracted to buy almost $200 million of term loans and then learned it was on the list.
Why does selling a loan transfer its legal claims?
Under general contract law, someone who takes an assignment of a contract steps into the seller's position and receives its rights. Loan trading relies on standard assignment forms, including those published by the Loan Syndications and Trading Association. Those forms pass along the seller's interest in the loan together with its claims against the borrower and others. The seller keeps nothing to sue on, and the buyer inherits whatever the seller could have recovered.
Why does loan trading rely on phone calls?
Loans are private contracts without a central exchange or a public price feed. A seller usually asks several dealer desks for bids, and each dealer decides how much it will pay and for how much size. Each trade settles through an assignment that must be documented and often approved by the agent bank and the borrower. This process has historically taken longer to complete than a bond trade.
Why can a borrower approve who buys its loans?
Many credit agreements require the borrower's consent before a lender can assign its loans to a new holder. The purpose is to give the company some control over who sits in its lender group, since lenders can vote on amendments and waivers. These consent rights commonly fall away when the borrower is in payment default. Some agreements also bar assignments to named competitors or investors on a disqualified lender list.
More from Law, disrupted
