A Daughter Backed Her Father's Story, Then Testified It Was a Lie
Police bugged a secret phone, then tested her new account with details only the person who dumped the purse could know.

Dateline NBC · Deadly IntersectionOn a wiretapped call, Valeria Smith shouted at her father: "you're leaving me here to take the fall." "You're abandoning me."
Keith tried to calm her. He called her baby girl, said he had her, and promised to send her something so they could keep talking. Detective Jill Beauregard said investigators knew immediately that "it was probably a cell phone."
It was a brand-new mobile phone. Police stopped the parcel before delivery, bugged the phone, put it back in the box, and sent it on to her house so they could keep listening.
Valeria had been in the car when her stepmother, Jacqueline Smith, was stabbed. She had backed Keith's account that panhandlers, people asking drivers for money, had killed her, and she later fled with him. Now she would become the prosecution's key witness against him.
Her turn came at what prosecutors called a proffer session. Valeria was offered the chance of a lighter charge if she told the truth, with one lie enough to void the deal. This time she said Keith was the killer.
She said he told her they had to tell the story or they would both go to jail. Valeria Smith described the panhandler story Keith gave police this way: "It's the most dumbest story ever."
Prosecutors said they were skeptical because she had lied to them repeatedly. So they tested her with details that had never been made public.
One test was Jacqueline's pocketbook. Valeria said she left it on a bus bench, waited, and watched teenagers pick it up. Investigators had already recovered the cards from juveniles who said they found the wallet, and the bus-stop account matched.
Her lawyer, Brandon Meade, said Keith's request that Valeria get rid of the wallet looked like a setup, a way to claim deniability and shift blame to her. Once she saw the manipulation, Meade said, she decided he needed to take accountability.
Prosecutors said other details fit, including that the white pants Valeria wore that night showed no blood. They also pointed to a diary she kept during three days on the run about not wanting to go to prison for what someone else did.
Valeria Smith said she never wanted to flee: "I just did not want my father to leave me high and dry and for me to take the fall for his crime." Prosecutors said they believed Keith was the mastermind and murderer, but the defense argued Valeria had chances to tell the truth and made a deal only after learning what punishment she could face.
Questions people ask
What was Keith Smith's original panhandler story?
Keith said a woman holding what looked like a baby asked Jacqueline to lower her car window for 10 dollars, then a male companion stabbed Jacqueline and the woman grabbed her purse. Police first chased the account, clearing teenagers who used the stolen cards and a couple named by a tipster, before phone and camera evidence pointed to Keith and Valeria.
What happened to Keith Smith at trial?
A jury convicted Keith of first-degree murder after about a day and a half of deliberations. He was sentenced to life plus three years. He had previously served seven years for bank robbery.
What deal did Valeria get for testifying?
Valeria agreed to testify in exchange for pleading to accessory to murder after the fact. She served less than three years. The defense argued she lied to save herself, while prosecutors said corroboration showed she was telling the truth.


