A Director Told Daniel Day-Lewis His Character Was Not Working
Shepard says they reshot the first week and landed on the character he and his friends love.

Armchair Expert with Dax Shepard · Mom's Car: Nat FaxonActor Dax Shepard said the most striking directing story he had seen came while watching Charlie Rose interview director Paul Thomas Anderson and actor Daniel Day-Lewis.
Rose asked whether it was true they had scrapped the first week or two of filming There Will Be Blood. Shepard said the two men exchanged a look, as if deciding whether to share it, then said yes.
In Shepard's retelling, Day-Lewis said they had shot for a week when Anderson asked him to watch dailies with him over the weekend. Dailies are the rough footage shot each day, and Day-Lewis told Anderson he does not watch them.
Anderson answered that he knew that, but he was asking anyway. The two men then watched the full first week together, as Shepard told it.
At the end, Anderson told Day-Lewis he did not think his character worked for the movie. Shepard said he was stunned by the conviction it took to tell a star known for deep preparation that his choice did not fit.
Shepard said he wondered how a director could conclude he knew the character better than Day-Lewis. That certainty, Shepard said, is why Anderson is an incredible director.
Shepard said he would have assumed Day-Lewis was probably right and tried to live with footage he did not want. Anderson instead asked to start over.
Shepard said they reshot the whole first week and landed on the character he and his friends love. He said he did not know what the first character had been, only that the one Day-Lewis landed on was spectacular.
Shepard said Anderson and Day-Lewis told the story carefully, as if protective of the process. He said he was grateful they shared it.
Actor Nat Faxon, speaking with Shepard, said most actors want reassurance from a director, praise for good work and encouragement to do more. In this case, the note was the opposite, to set aside a week of work and try again.
Questions people ask
What are dailies?
Dailies are the unedited footage shot during a day of film production, usually reviewed by the director and key crew. The term comes from the old practice of developing film overnight so it could be watched the next day.
Who is Paul Thomas Anderson?
Paul Thomas Anderson is an American filmmaker known for large, character driven films including Boogie Nights, Magnolia, and Phantom Thread. He writes and directs his own work and is known for close collaboration with actors over long shoots.
Why was it such a big deal to tell Daniel Day-Lewis to change?
Day-Lewis is known for deep preparation and total immersion in roles, so directors rarely question his choices. In Shepard's telling, the point was Anderson's conviction that he knew what the film needed, even when the star had made a different choice.

