A Sample of a Medium's Ghostly Material Was Likely Swallowed Cheesecloth
In near darkness, fabric she likely swallowed looked like ghostly material leaving her mouth, until light and a lab test gave it away.

After Dark: Myths, Misdeeds & the Paranormal · The Witch Trial of World War TwoA sample of Helen Duncan's famous ghostly material was cheesecloth that she supposedly drew out of her own body.
The setting made the trick possible. Guests came to her house and sat in a connected circle in a room so dark they could barely see each other, which hid flaws that would have been obvious in daylight.
Once seated, Duncan was blindfolded and held at the wrists while she claimed to produce ectoplasm from her mouth. Ectoplasm was supposed to be spiritual energy that took physical form, and could shape itself into a dead person.
Flash photographs taken during sittings show what the darkness concealed. A white tube runs from her face to crude, puppetlike figures beside her, with painted faces that look homemade and rough.
Those faces looked almost wooden to the two presenters who examined the photographs. They guessed, with no evidence, that Duncan's husband, a cabinet maker who could no longer do that work after being hurt, might have made masks for the figures.
A sample of the supposed ectoplasm obtained by psychical researcher Harry Price was tested by a chemist and identified as cheesecloth. The finding applied to that sample, not to every material Duncan ever used.
The method was likely bodily as well as theatrical. She likely hid the cloth before a sitting, perhaps by swallowing it, and then regurgitated it in front of guests so it seemed to stream from her mouth and nose.
The material hung within reach of the circle. Other people at sittings sometimes grabbed it during the performance.
Questions people ask
What was ectoplasm supposed to be?
Ectoplasm was said to be a physical substance produced by a medium's body that could form into a spirit. It was a common claim among mediums in the 1920s and 1930s, and it was usually said to emerge from the mouth or nose.
What exactly is cheesecloth?
Cheesecloth is a loose, lightweight cotton gauze used in cooking for straining liquids and wrapping cheese. It is thin, pale, and wispy, which would have helped it look ghostly in almost total darkness.
Was swallowing and bringing up cloth dangerous?
Yes. Cloth can block the airway, cause choking or vomiting, and injure the throat and esophagus. Repeated swallowing also risks infection, especially when the same material is stored on the body and handled by other people.


