KorvaJoin the waitlist
Tech

America Should Keep Analog Backups for Critical Systems

Joe Kent argues backups for the grid, air traffic, and dams would protect the country and give displaced workers jobs.

AI image
The Tucker Carlson Show · What Inside Sources Say Is Causing Nationwide Tech Outages & Why the Timing Matters

Joe Kent, who until recently led the National Counterterrorism Center, was asked about a string of alarming reports when he offered a different kind of defense.

The discussion had covered a late October cyberattack described as knocking out large parts of the internet, reported British advice to store extra drinking water and preserved food, and a Pentagon direction for American military bases to operate alone for three months without relying on surrounding power, water, or fuel supplies.

Kent said the country should have parallel analog systems for critical infrastructure. “We should have parallel systems that run all of our critical infrastructure that are analog,” he said.

By that, he means people as well as equipment. He described trained crews who could run the Federal Aviation Administration, dams, and other critical infrastructure in a more analog fashion if the cyber system failed.

Kent tied the idea to what he sees as an imbalance in priorities. He said the United States has put its energy into winning the race in artificial intelligence and quantum technology, while ways to harden the power grid and protect people at home have atrophied or fallen away.

He pointed to his own lifetime as evidence that an analog fallback is possible. Kent, 46, noted that in the 1990s the country ran without the internet and without artificial intelligence, and he believes government should refocus on protecting citizens.

The proposal also has a jobs argument, in his telling. Kent said redundant analog systems would need workers, and could employ people who lose work as artificial intelligence spreads.

Kent is skeptical of the competing answer he hears from Washington, that tighter government regulation and closed artificial intelligence systems will be more secure. He said that case is difficult to sell given how technology has been used, and that officials have not clearly explained their warnings about open systems and China.

Questions people ask

What would an analog backup for air traffic control actually look like?

Air traffic control already combines radar, radio, and computer processing to track planes and guide landings. An analog fallback would rely more on older radar scopes, voice radio procedures, and manual flight strips, which controllers used for decades, but it would handle far fewer flights and require regular practice.

Can a modern dam really be run by hand?

Most large dams use digital controls for gates, sensors, and power generation, but their basic operations are mechanical. Workers can open and close gates by hand or with local hydraulic controls, read gauges directly, and coordinate by radio or phone, though it is slower and needs trained operators on site.

What does hardening the power grid usually involve?

Utilities keep spare transformers, use manual switches, and practice restoring power in sections rather than all at once. Hardening can also include physical protection, backup communications that do not depend on the internet, and stockpiled parts, all of which take funding and maintenance.

More in Tech