KorvaJoin the waitlist
Psychology

An Author Sought A Cross-Aisle Interview. The Free Press Shelved It.

He says he cleared his publication-day schedule for the exchange, then got different reasons for why it would not run.

AI image
status.news · The Free Press’ Follies

Anand Giridharadas arrived for a taping on Sept. 29, the day his new book came out, entering a Manhattan office tower he had never visited before.

The session lasted about an hour, with Free Press writer Olivia Reingold asking the questions. She is one of the outlet's best known reporters. The subject was his just released book, Man in the Mirror.

The book revisits the prosecution of Daniel Penny, a former Marine who killed subway rider Jordan Neely with a neck hold and later won a not guilty verdict. Both participants had reported on the proceedings. The episode split New York and fueled wider arguments about safety, order, and racial division.

Giridharadas says the appearance was his idea. He set aside most of that launch day calendar because he hoped a conversation across political lines would find listeners outside his usual readership, and he felt the recording achieved that goal.

Leaders at the Weiss founded publication chose not to release the recording. Publications can make that call, but Giridharadas says the aftermath puzzled him.

He says days passed quietly after the late September recording. In early October he messaged Reingold to check on timing, and she answered with a no. The choice, she told him, was unrelated to his opinions.

According to Giridharadas, a different account soon reached his team. He says Josh Kaplan, an editor at the outlet, emailed the representative for the book to say the shoot had not gone as planned and was not suitable to publish, adding that Reingold might produce an article instead.

Giridharadas says that alternative never appeared, and a message he sent Kaplan on Nov. 5 received no reply. During the wait, Giridharadas wondered if it was “a blog that got a lot of money or an actual publication.”

What stung, Giridharadas said, was the contrast with an A.I. altered photo the outlet had published. “You had a literally non-human piece of content,” he said, “and a profoundly human piece of content.”

“It saddens me greatly that of those two, they chose to publish the former and kill the latter,” Giridharadas said.

Questions people ask

Who is Anand Giridharadas?

Giridharadas is a writer and commentator known for books about inequality and American life, including Winners Take All. He often writes about wealth, democracy, and culture, and appears frequently as a political analyst.

What is The Free Press?

The Free Press was founded in 2021 by former New York Times opinion editor Bari Weiss as a subscription publication critical of mainstream media and progressive orthodoxies. It covers politics and culture, and was acquired in 2025 as Weiss took a top role at CBS News.

What happened in the Daniel Penny case?

Penny was acquitted of criminal charges in the 2023 death of Neely on a subway car. The verdict ended the criminal case, though the episode continued to fuel debate over safety, mental illness, homelessness, and race in New York.

More in Psychology