Cowen Says Chess Players Saw AI Coming Because Chess Is About Intuition
Once a computer could play chess well, Cowen argues, it showed machines could display judgment that would work elsewhere.

Tetragrammaton with Rick Rubin · Tyler CowenIn a long conversation about artificial intelligence, economist Tyler Cowen offered an explanation for why chess players were among the earliest people to grasp what AI would become.
He pointed to fellow chess players he knows, like former world champion Kasparov, and said they tuned into AI early. The reason, Cowen argued, was not enthusiasm about computers. It was a clearer view of what chess actually requires.
Most outsiders, he said, think chess is about calculation. On that view, a machine that calculates faster is doing nothing fundamentally new, only doing arithmetic at greater speed.
People who play at a higher level see the game differently, Cowen said: “they know chess is mainly about intuition and understanding.”
That distinction changed the meaning of computer chess, in Cowen’s telling. When computers began to play the game well, players did not see faster calculation. Cowen put their reaction simply: “oh, they can do intuition and understanding.”
Cowen said he understood that for decades. If a machine could display that kind of judgment on a chessboard, he reasoned, then it was only a matter of time before machines could display intuition and understanding in other areas.
Outsiders missed that signal, Cowen argued, because they had misunderstood chess from the start. Players recognized computer chess as intuition and understanding, and drew the broader lesson. “And of course, it happened,” he said.
Questions people ask
Why would chess require intuition?
Strong players rely on pattern recognition, positional judgment, and a feel for which plans are promising, rather than calculating every possible move. There are too many positions to calculate exhaustively, so experience guides them toward the handful of moves worth serious attention.
When did computers start beating the best chess players?
IBM's Deep Blue defeated world champion Garry Kasparov in a 1997 rematch, and computer programs soon advanced well beyond the best humans. Modern chess engines now routinely beat even elite grandmasters, and most top players train with them.

