KorvaJoin the waitlist
Startups

Falling New Customers Signal Trouble Years Before Revenue Does

Existing customers who renew and pay more can keep revenue growing while the pool of new buyers shrinks.

AI image
The Twenty Minute VC (20VC): Venture Capital | Startup Funding | The Pitch · 20VC: Will Jensen Return to NVIDIA | Anthropic Set for Largest IPO of All Time | Kalshi, Mercor & Fractile: Mega-Rounds Continue

For years, HubSpot added about 10,000 net new customers every quarter, like clockwork. Then it added about 6,000, then 5,000, and then guided below 5,000.

Monday.com showed a sharper version of the same pattern in one segment. It went from about 1,200 net new customers with 10 or more seats to fewer than 200, a fall of roughly 80%.

Investor Jason Lemkin calls net new customers his lighthouse metric, meaning the signal he watches most closely. He says "It is the only thing that matters at scale."

Why does the drop in new buyers take so long to show up in revenue? Existing customers keep renewing, buy more products, and absorb price increases, so a company with decent retention and higher prices can mask growth for several years.

Lemkin says a software business that stops attracting net new customers faces terminal trouble or, in his words, "you're into deep value mode ... because there are no new customers."

Venture investor Rory O'Driscoll says part of the problem is that software markets can fill up. He says some markets are more finite than people think, and it is hard to grow customer counts indefinitely, especially with larger business customers.

HubSpot already has 320,000 customers, while Salesforce, with about $50 billion in revenue, has stopped disclosing its customer count. O'Driscoll says he anticipated a slowdown as markets such as customer management software saturated, not simply because artificial intelligence would replace them.

Questions people ask

Why doesn't revenue show the problem right away?

Revenue counts money from old and new customers together. If old customers stay and pay more, total revenue can keep growing even when few new customers arrive, which can hide weaker demand for several years.

What is retention, and why does it help mask the slowdown?

It measures how much revenue a company keeps from the same group of customers over time, including upgrades, added seats, and price increases. A rate above 100% means existing accounts are spending more than they did the year before.

Does a fall in new customers mean a company is doomed?

Not necessarily, but growth is harder because the easy buyers are gone. The company must win tougher customers, sell much more to current ones, or create a very different product.

More in Startups