KorvaJoin the waitlist
Tech

Google Salespeople Could Not Set the Price or the Volume

Advertisers bought search ads in an auction, so the job was teaching them what to bid.

AI image
David Senra · Building a $250B Cybersecurity Giant | Nikesh Arora, Palo Alto Networks

Nikesh Arora, who once led Google's sales in Europe and now leads Palo Alto Networks, remembers customers asking two basic questions about search ads: how much does it cost, and how much can I buy.

On both, he had the same awkward answer: he did not know. Price was set by other advertisers, and volume was set by ordinary people typing searches.

Google sold ads through bids. What an advertiser paid depended on competing offers, including what the last bidder had offered and how much the next advertiser was willing to pay to top it. Arora had no price list to hand over.

He also had no inventory to guarantee. Google could show an ad only when someone searched, so the sales team could not promise a set number of views in a day.

When it rained in France, he said, revenue rose because more people stayed home and searched. The sales team did not control that supply.

So Arora changed the pitch from price to math. He sat with advertisers and worked out what one visitor was worth, using the conversion rate, the share of searchers who went on to complete a purchase such as an insurance policy or an online order.

From that number, they set a maximum bid they could afford while still earning a return on investment. Then the instruction was simple: keep buying matching searches as long as each result comes in below that bid.

Questions people ask

Why would an advertiser accept a deal with no fixed price or volume?

Because they could set a ceiling. An advertiser decided the most it could pay for a visitor and still make money, and Google would not exceed that bid. If the math worked, an uncertain price and volume were acceptable because each purchase was expected to be profitable.

Do Google ads still work this way today?

Yes, in its essentials. Google still sells search ads through auctions in which advertisers set maximum bids for clicks. The system has added more automated bidding and measurement, but the price still reflects rival demand and the volume still reflects what people search.

What stops a rich company from just outbidding everyone every time?

Not necessarily for long. An unlimited budget still loses money if each click costs more than the customer is worth. Google also weighs factors like relevance and ad quality, so a smaller advertiser with a tightly matched ad can sometimes win useful searches without paying the highest price.

More in Tech