KorvaJoin the waitlist
Relationships

He Called 911 Outside The ER Instead Of Rushing His Wife In

Holt said the suspicion was that Keith was waiting for his wife to die outside the emergency room.

AI image
Dateline NBC · Talking Dateline: Deadly Intersection

The emergency room was steps away, with doctors and nurses just inside the doors. In the ambulance bay outside, a husband stood with a phone to his ear, calling 911 about his stabbed wife.

The caller was Keith Smith. He said his wife, Jacqueline Smith, had been stabbed by panhandlers while she was riding in a car with him and his daughter Valeria.

Lester Holt, the NBC journalist who covered the case, said it "really touched a lot of fears people have about homeless people, about people collecting money on the streets," and Keith's call set off a huge manhunt. It ended with a different outcome: Valeria pleaded guilty to accessory after the fact and testified against her father, and Keith was convicted of first-degree murder.

Investigators began by testing the story against video and location evidence of where the three said they had been that night. That evidence showed Keith had not been where he claimed to be.

Then detectives reviewed surveillance footage from the hospital. It showed Keith standing outside in the ambulance bay while he spoke to the 911 dispatcher, rather than carrying or dragging Jacqueline through the doors and shouting for help.

There was no visible panic and no rush inside, though help was steps away. For detectives, the urgency in his words did not match up with the stillness in his actions.

Holt said the suspicion was that he was waiting for her to die. When detectives matched the video to the call, it became a key clue.

For a long stretch, police questioned Keith without letting on that he was a suspect. He and Valeria stuck closely to their shared account while detectives quietly collected video evidence and used a wiretap to monitor their calls.

He was at the hospital with help inside, and he stayed outside.

Questions people ask

Why did police doubt the panhandler story?

Holt said he asked every law enforcement person he interviewed whether they had ever had a case of a homeless person or panhandler attacking anyone unprovoked, and they all shook their heads no. Police also looked at a couple of other suspects who seemed promising at first, but those leads were not the case. Holt said that breakdown was one of the first signs the story was crumbling.

What did investigators think the motive was?

Holt said Jacqueline had an $800,000 life insurance policy, and police zeroed in on that amount. Answering a listener question, he said investigators believed Keith acted to improve his standard of living after her death. Holt added his personal view that there may have been more to it, but said he was not an investigator.

What happened to the daughter, and who was Jacqueline?

Valeria Smith pleaded guilty to accessory after the fact in exchange for testifying against her father. Canning noted Jacqueline was an electrical engineer at Aberdeen Proving Ground, and Holt confirmed she did sophisticated work there and was adored by colleagues. Keith was convicted of first-degree murder.

More in Relationships