Investigate in Public, One Episode at a Time
He targeted local listeners first, then let their tips shape each week's episode.

The Shawn Ryan Show · #357 Payne Lindsey - “He Was the First Monster I Ever Really Encountered”Payne Lindsey, creator and host of the true crime podcast Up and Vanished, had no investigative background when he took on the disappearance of Tara Grinstead, a schoolteacher and former pageant queen who vanished in October 2005.
He decided to investigate in public. Before the first episode, he paid for Instagram promotion aimed at Osceola to let people know the show was coming and to drum up interest among people who knew the story and cared about Grinstead.
Attention spread quickly from the town of about 3,000 people to the rest of Georgia. As each installment came out, information that had been held back started coming out as listeners reacted in real time.
He began with the safest source he could think of, his grandmother. She lived about 20 minutes away, and her close friend Melba had seen Grinstead on the night she disappeared.
His grandmother introduced him to Melba, and Melba introduced him to others. That chain opened new interviews and led him to people who had been close to Grinstead.
After about six months of research, he released the first episode and promised the second the next Monday, even though he had used all his interviews and had nothing ready.
The weekly deadline created a direct line to the community. Sometimes a tip he received made it into the show the same day, reshaped into a reported episode with a cliffhanger, and he could rebuild the timeline that night instead of waiting months.
The first episode drew 5,000 downloads in a week, which he took to be mostly the town plus his own followers, and local news outlets soon picked it up. He jokes that he helped create a trope, and usually advises aspiring true crime podcasters not to do it.
Questions people ask
Who was Tara Grinstead?
She was a schoolteacher and former pageant queen, described as a beauty queen, who disappeared in October 2005. Lindsey picked the case from a state list of unsolved crimes about 11 years later because the circumstances left many unclosed loops.
How can you advertise a podcast to one town?
Lindsey said he ran Instagram ads in Osceola before the first episode to announce the show. He said the first episode drew 5,000 downloads in seven days, which he guessed were mostly town listeners plus his own followers. The town is about 3,000 people.
Why release the investigation week by week?
Lindsey said the weekly promise forced him to keep reporting and let him use new tips right away. Listeners reacted in real time, so he could rebuild the timeline that night and end episodes with cliffhangers. The tradeoff is constant pressure.


