Judge Competition by What Outsiders Can Actually Do
A study of Amazon uses six observable checks to test whether rivals, workers, sellers, and customers have workable alternatives.

atlantis-press.com · Value Creation, Market Power, and the Legitimacy of Entrepreneurial Wealth: A Critical-Case Analysis of Amazon and Jeff Bezos | Atlantis PressHanyu Zhang, an author affiliated with Shanghai Thomas School in Shanghai, wanted a practical way to judge when entrepreneurial wealth stays tied to creating value.
His answer was to stop treating competition as an abstract idea and to watch what outsiders can actually do.
He judges effective competition through six observable signs: entry by new rivals, switching by customers, multi-homing, or using more than one option at once, worker mobility to other jobs, price or wage responses when rivals appear or disappear, and access to alternative sales channels.
Zhang applied the checks to Amazon, which he treats as a theory-revealing example rather than a typical company, so the findings illuminate how the mechanisms work but cannot show how common they are.
In that case, his review found major benefits from online retail, delivery networks, and platform tools, alongside bounded evidence of labor pressure and platform power in particular warehouse settings, product categories, and regions.
The paper cautions that the evidence cannot be used to calculate what share of Jeff Bezos's wealth comes from innovation rather than economic rent, meaning income from market power rather than from creating value.
The method is not a general test. The paper limits its wider use to online platforms led by their founders that both operate a marketplace and sell in it, where users depend heavily on the platform.
Questions people ask
Why study Amazon if it is not a typical company?
Because Amazon is treated as a theory-revealing critical case, not as a statistically representative firm. It combines large-scale logistics with a marketplace it both governs and sells in, where workers and sellers depend on the platform. Such a case can clarify how a mechanism works, even if it cannot show how common it is.
Does failing one of these checks prove a company is a monopoly?
No. A single weak spot may reflect only one job type, product category, or region, and it does not establish a broad pattern across all of a company's markets. The study's 100-point protocol weighs evidence by directness, identification strength, scope fit, independence, and finality, and it resolves conflicting evidence under explicit rules.
What is economic rent?
It means income sustained by market power rather than by creating additional value. Zhang argues that entrepreneurial wealth becomes harder to defend when measurable limits on alternatives sustain returns without a matching productive contribution.


