KorvaJoin the waitlist
Startups

Keep Your Best Product Managers Building Products, Not Managing Them

Tom Verrilli says senior leaders should keep doing the hands-on work rather than adding a layer of managers, starting with support tickets, data, and specs.

AI image
Lenny's Podcast: Product | Growth | Career · This CPO regrets that product management exists | Tom Verrilli (CPO of Whatnot)

Tom Verrilli, who was chief product officer of Whatnot when he was interviewed in August 2026, was asked why he was excited about senior product managers returning to hands-on work. He answered with soccer.

"Why wouldn't you want Messi playing for your team rather than trying to have the academy coming along all the time?" Verrilli said. By academy, he meant a youth development program that trains future players.

Verrilli argued that tech rewarded the opposite of keeping stars on the field. It promoted strong product managers out of hands-on work and into management.

In a setup he calls ratio land, he means the hiring rule of adding a designer and a product manager for every set number of engineers. There, a successful product manager was promoted to director and told not to be hands-on anymore.

The job became coaching, guiding, and alignment, and work bounced back and forth in reviews. Verrilli said, "We took all of our A players and then promoted them out of doing things."

In the August 2026 interview, he said there were four or five people at Whatnot who managed other product managers, and all of them spent more than 90 percent of their time doing individual contributor work. That means doing the product work themselves rather than managing others. He put himself at about 50 percent.

For a product manager, he said, that work means being in the support tickets, pulling the data yourself, querying the code base, writing the specification, and running the standup. He said he had shipped production code at Whatnot, but someone quietly reworked most of it to fix code style, translation, and other details he and his AI coding helper missed.

The payoff, in his view, is speed and judgment. Someone with a decade or 15 years of building, he said, has well honed instincts and can make decisions more quickly. That person can also handle the workload of multiple junior managers and sees more of the product's moving parts at once.

It can also cost less, he argued. Add up the pay for five junior product managers reporting to a midlevel manager, plus four of those managers reporting to a vice president, and he said it is easier to pay three effective senior individuals at vice president level for the same impact.

The model only works if leaders stay close to the ground, he said. He pointed to a meeting where someone dismisses a result as fraud because the data labels it that way, but no one knows how it got labeled. An experienced director, he said, would go find out and likely strengthen the labeling system. His rule is to do fewer things and do them fully, with the best people in the weeds.

Questions people ask

Can an individual contributor really make as much money as a vice president?

That is Verrilli's argument. He says to take the budget for that layered team and pay three high impact senior individuals at vice president level instead. Generally speaking, many tech companies have pay bands where top individual pay can overlap with manager pay.

Isn't this just micromanagement by another name?

Verrilli does not frame it that way in these remarks. His point is practical: leaders who stay close to tickets, data, and code understand how a result was produced. In his fraud example, that means digging into how the label gets applied and improving that system.

Does this mean Whatnot has no product managers who manage people?

No. In August 2026 he said four or five people on his team managed other product managers, but management was a small part of their jobs. The change he described was that promotion did not mean giving up the product work itself.

More in Startups