Most People Don't Need Toner
Four dermatologists agree toner is not needed for most people, with Dr. Schwarzburg pointing to modern cleansers and Dr. Westbay preferring serums.
Four of the five dermatologists asked to audit a crowded skincare routine say most people can skip toner. It was the clearest consensus in the group.
“Toner is not a requirement for being a functioning adult with skin,” said Dr. Rachel Westbay, a dermatologist. She said a serum delivers helpful ingredients more effectively than toner.
Dr. Jenna Queller, a dermatologist, said toner would be the first thing she would cut, especially if you already use a gentle cleanser, treatment, and moisturizer. Dr. Dmitriy Schwarzburg, a dermatologist, said modern cleansers have made toner inessential for most people.
Both Dr. Schwarzburg and Dr. Marie Jhin, a dermatologist, warned that astringent or alcohol-based toners can dry, strip, or irritate skin. A hydrating toner may feel pleasant, Dr. Jhin said, but it is not a step you need.
Questions people ask
Is there anyone who should still use toner?
No broad group was carved out in the audit. If you like the feel of a gentle, hydrating toner and it does not sting or dry you out, you can keep it. People who want exfoliation or oil control usually get more reliable results from a targeted treatment recommended by a dermatologist.
What should I buy instead of toner?
Most dermatologists recommend keeping the core simple: a gentle cleanser, a moisturizer that suits your skin, and daily broad spectrum sunscreen of SPF 30 or higher. Then add one targeted product only if you have a specific concern, such as acne, dark spots, or fine lines.
Can toner actually harm my skin?
It can, especially the old style astringent formulas with alcohol or witch hazel. Those products can remove oil too aggressively and leave skin dry, tight, red, or stinging. If your face feels tight after toning, that is a sign to stop using it.