One Cookie Chain Grew From a Dorm Room, the Other From a Tech Playbook
Private equity turned a dorm-room cookie into a national chain, while Crumbl chased the perfect recipe through testing.

Marketplace · The Fed vs. AI inflationIn the early 2000s, a college student in Boston started baking cookies in his dorm-room oven. He figured students on campus wanted cookies.
That dorm-room fix became Insomnia Cookies. After private-equity investors came in, the chain kept expanding until it reached more than 300 shops across the country and in other countries.
It is one version of how a simple cookie gets big. Another cookie chain took the opposite path, treating the recipe itself like a technology problem.
The interview framed the Insomnia expansion with a pointed premise, that adding stores had not made the cookies any better. Smith answered bluntly, "Well, they were never particularly good cookies to begin with." She described them as simple.
The contrast, Smith said, is Crumbl, which wants to sell gourmet, fancy cookies. It was started in Utah by two relatives, one who came from tech and one who came from marketing.
Smith said, "They built their cookie company like a tech company." The founders tested one cookie against another, a method that compares two versions to see which performs better.
Their goal in that testing, Smith said, was trying "to make the best chocolate chip cookie ever" through a recipe process conducted "without at any point consulting a chef."
The two paths point to a broader pattern Smith described for restaurants. A concept that can be copied from place to place, especially through franchises, is the kind of repeatable expansion that draws private-equity money.
One cookie grew as investors helped copy a basic shop into hundreds of places. The other aimed for gourmet, fancy cookies through testing.
Questions people ask
What does private equity actually do with a restaurant chain?
Private equity firms buy a stake in a business, often with borrowed money, and try to grow it quickly and sell it or take it public for a profit. With restaurants, they like concepts that can be copied in many locations and run with franchise operators.
What is A/B testing when it comes to food?
It is a way of comparing two options, called A and B, to see which one people prefer. A company might offer two recipes to customers, measure sales or ratings, keep the winner, and then test again.
Why would investors want to back a cookie shop?
Mostly consistency, low costs, and a store format that can be repeated. Investors tend to favor simple menus, inexpensive ingredients, and late-night or takeout demand that fits near colleges and busy streets.

