KorvaJoin the waitlist
History

Patriots Burned Benedict Arnold With The Devil To Rally The Cause

With the Revolution faltering in 1780, one fiery street show helped turn shock over a celebrated general into solidarity.

AI image
American Scandal · Benedict Arnold | The Politics of Betrayal | 5

In Philadelphia in 1780, a huge crowd gathered around a rolling stage carrying two figures made of papier-mache. One was the Devil. The other was Benedict Arnold, shown as his partner.

The show had been staged by Charles Wilson Peale, an artist and former officer in the Continental Army, the American force fighting Britain. At the finale, the crowd watched the float go up in flames, with Arnold burning beside the Devil.

The burning was a deliberate act of persuasion. It drew a huge crowd and wide newspaper coverage, and it helped rally people behind the Patriots.

The shock was real, says historian Alan Taylor. Arnold was probably the most celebrated American battlefield commander, known for reckless courage and for winning against long odds. His exposure as a man secretly helping Britain against Washington and the American army stunned the public.

The timing made it more dangerous. It was 1780, and Patriots were suffering defeats in the southern states. There was hyperinflation, widespread desertion because Congress could not pay or supply soldiers, quarreling among the states, and a Congress that was broke.

There was real fear that Arnold's defection could tip the cause into collapse. The damage was contained because the plot was uncovered in time, so Arnold could not surrender the stronghold at West Point and its troops, and had to flee himself.

Patriot leaders moved quickly to use the emotion. Washington, the American commander, insisted that John Andre, the captured British go-between who had helped Arnold, be hanged. Many of Washington's own officers, even Alexander Hamilton, regarded Andre with fellow feeling as a gentleman officer, but Washington refused to spare him.

Taylor calls that resolve one of Washington's finest moments. It steadied the army, and it appealed to the public.

Peale contributed to rallying people behind the Patriots. The effigies held Arnold up for public abuse, meant to get Americans to say they would not be Arnold.

Not everyone joined in. About a fifth of Americans remained active Loyalists, working hard to keep the empire together. But for Patriots, the image of Arnold burning with the Devil helped turn a moment of betrayal into support.

Questions people ask

Why was West Point so important?

West Point was an American fort on the Hudson River in New York, designed to block British movement between New England and the rest of the colonies. Its soldiers, cannons, and control of the river made it one of the most valuable military prizes of the war.

What happened to John Andre after his capture?

Andre was a British Army officer who acted as the contact between Arnold and the British command. After his capture, Washington had him executed as a spy in October 1780. Arnold, who had fled to British lines, became a British brigadier general.

More in History