A Child Assault Case Was Dropped While the Informant Kept Testifying
She passed a lie detector test and two people said they saw glimpses of the assault, but the case went away.

Criminal · The InformantA 12-year-old girl walked into the local sheriff's office alongside her mother and father to accuse a man of sexually assaulting her.
Her name was Karen Parker. The man she accused was Paul Skalnik, a jail inmate turned prosecution witness who told authorities that fellow inmates awaiting trial had confessed to him.
A jailhouse informant is an inmate who reports those supposed confessions, often with the hope of lighter punishment. Skalnik knew that hope well.
He had been facing five years behind bars when he began feeding prosecutors details in low level drug cases where convictions were uncertain. After he delivered, his sentence became probation.
Within five months of that release, he was taken into custody again on a theft allegation. Within days of that custody, Karen came forward with her report.
The investigation treated the two sides differently. Karen, at 12, was given a polygraph exam, a lie detector test that people at the time believed could show truthfulness. She passed. Skalnik was never tested.
Two other people also said they had caught partial views of what happened. He was charged with lewd and lascivious conduct on a child under 14, a felony carrying up to 15 years in prison.
The charge landed at an inconvenient moment. Skalnik had agreed to appear as a witness in additional prosecutions, and prosecutors had seen how effective he was on the stand.
When he took the stand, he would present himself as a former officer. As reporter Pamela Colloff described his pitch, he would say, "I was a former police officer. Law enforcement is in my blood, and I got in a little bit of financial trouble, but I'm a good guy."
Colloff said that timing mattered for the prosecution, because Skalnik was expected to keep testifying, and that kind of charge would have changed his claim to be a good guy. Prosecutors dismissed the charges, and he was never prosecuted.
The Pinellas County State Attorney's Office said previously that it never provided leniency to Skalnik in exchange for testimony, and that all information he provided was independently verified.
Karen was left, as reporter Pamela Colloff put it, "made to feel that no one believes her."
Even inside her own family, she was not believed. She was seen as a troublemaker. She ran away from home, and told Colloff she "didn't trust anyone for a long, long time."
Skalnik pleaded no contest on the theft charges. Instead of a possible 15 years, he received five years with credit for time served.
Prosecutors asked that he remain in the county jail rather than go to state prison. They said he could be in danger from men he had helped convict.
Colloff said there was another reason. In prison, among already convicted men, he was of no use. In jail, among men awaiting trial, he could keep supplying cases.
Years later in Texas, Skalnik molested his wife's 16-year-old daughter, Misty Anderson. Because the Karen Parker case had never moved through the courts, he was treated as if he had no previous sex conviction.
He received a 10-year term and remained behind bars the entire time.
Questions people ask
What did Skalnik do after finishing the Texas prison term?
He was released in 2002 after serving the full 10 years, then left Texas without registering as a sex offender as required. In Boston, he posed as a lawyer named Avery Harrison, took thousands of dollars from clients, and did little or no work. A little more than a year after his release, he was arrested again on charges of larceny and unauthorized practice of law.
Why is jailhouse informant testimony seen as risky?
The informant often has a strong incentive to please prosecutors, such as hoped for leniency, while jurors may not hear the full history of that incentive. The supposed confession usually has no other witness. That combination has made such testimony a recurring factor in wrongful convictions.



