The Replication Crisis Hit Social Psychology Hardest, Not All of Psychology
The trouble primarily hit social psychology, most centrally social priming, a topic inside one chapter of a 16-chapter textbook.

Many commentators speak as though failed replications ruined the credibility of psychology, turning it into a cautionary tale for broken science. Writer Scott Alexander argues that this view gets the scale of the trouble wrong.
The crisis primarily hit one area, social psychology, and most centrally one small corner inside it. That corner is work on social priming, which tests whether tiny cues people barely notice can produce big shifts in what people do.
His measure is the table of contents of a free online textbook, OpenStax Psychology. In that book, social psychology is Chapter 12 of 16.
That one chapter holds social priming along with nearly everything critics love to hate, including power poses, nudges, stereotype threat and the Stanford Prison experiment. The other 15 chapters are “comparatively innocuous.”
Seen that way, the question is not whether psychology as a whole works. It is whether findings from one section inside one chapter should decide the reputation of the other 15.
Most of it, in his phrase, “consists of good ideas and trustworthy research.” Even its flawed parts tend to be fascinating in their oddity rather than boringly wrong.
As he puts it: “If you don’t like social priming, say that you don’t like social priming, and leave the rest of the field alone.”
Questions people ask
What is social priming, and what kind of finding failed to replicate?
Social priming is the idea that subtle cues, like words, images, or small environmental changes, can unconsciously shape later behavior in large ways. Famous claims included that thinking about old age makes people walk more slowly, and that holding a warm drink makes people judge strangers as warmer. Many of the most striking results did not hold up when other labs tried to repeat them.
What was the replication crisis?
The replication crisis refers to a period starting in the 2010s when researchers tried to repeat major findings in psychology and other fields, and many did not replicate. Large efforts found that only about one-third to one-half of selected results held up as originally described. The episode led to new standards around preregistration, larger samples, and sharing data and materials.
If social psychology is only one chapter, what is in the rest of psychology?
Introductory psychology covers sensation and perception, learning, memory, child development, personality, psychological disorders and therapy, brain function, and statistics and measurement. It also includes applied areas like industrial psychology, which studies hiring and workplace behavior, and health psychology. Most of that work uses different methods and questions than social priming experiments.


