KorvaJoin the waitlist
Relationships

She Said No to the Ride, Then Let Him Talk Her Into It

Her coworker saw the risk and spoke up, but the warning was dismissed as jealousy, and Tanya drove him home anyway.

AI image
American Scandal · LISTEN NOW: The First Wife

Late on a December night in 1988, the drinking and dancing were winding down at Shooters when John Meehan suddenly needed a ride. Tanya Bales, a 23-year-old nurse who had met him only hours earlier, was the person he asked.

Tanya says, "I was working a second shift in surgery at St. Elizabeth's Medical Center in Dayton, Ohio." She had come out after a 3-to-11 shift with about five coworkers, including her friend Terry Hardman, a surgical technician on the same operating room team.

That brief exchange about a ride, as Tanya tells it, became the opening to a 10-year relationship with John, her future husband and the father of her two daughters, a relationship she says included abuse and coercion.

As Tanya recalls it, John said, "I don't want to leave. Will you take me home? Will you give me a ride home?" She recalls answering, "No, I'm not giving you a ride home."

She says he kept pressing. He said, "Please, I want to hang out with you some more." Tanya recalls, "I just didn't know how to be firm in that no, because I did not want to drive him home," and adds, "Somehow I got talked into it."

Across the group, Terry was uneasy about Tanya staying behind while everyone else left. Terry recalls, "I was feeling like really uncomfortable, like, wow, I just, I don't know." Terry also recalls thinking, "I don't think that's a good idea."

Terry recalls raising that concern with someone else in the group. That person answered, "Oh, you know, you're just jealous." The warning went no further, and Tanya agreed to drive.

On the way, Tanya recalls, "I fully planned all the way home to pull up to the house, see you wouldn't want to be, thanks for the dance, and never see him again." Instead, she says, he convinced her to go inside once they arrived.

Looking back on agreeing to drive a stranger home, Tanya says, "Because now if you watch Dateline, people who do that, it doesn't end well, right?"

Questions people ask

Why do people often give in after they have already said no?

It is common because most people dislike conflict and want to seem polite, especially with someone who has been friendly. Repeated pleading adds pressure, and it can feel easier in the moment to give in than to repeat a refusal.

What is a safer way to handle a late-night ride request from a stranger?

Experts advise keeping the group together and not leaving alone with someone just met. If someone needs a ride, offer to call a taxi or rideshare, stay with friends, and treat a friend's discomfort as useful information rather than embarrassment.

Did Tanya hear from John again after that night?

Yes. Tanya says he used the workplace details she had shared to have her paged in the operating room during her next shift. When she answered, he said he had enjoyed their time together and asked her for a proper date.

More in Relationships