KorvaJoin the waitlist
Startups

Startup Cash Is a Risky Bet, Not a Debt to Keep Paying at Your Own Cost

YC partners say guilt keeps founders running companies they no longer believe will work, while hedged investors often do not care.

AI image
Dalton + Michael · Postmortem on a Dead Startup

Dalton and Michael, partners at YC, which funds young startups, say they have the same conversation with founders again and again. A founder tells them, “I am obligated to do X, Y, and Z to make sure that I can give my investors their money back.”

Their answer is blunt. “You were given this money to take a long shot bet.”

As they explain it, that feels strange because in normal life, when another person hands you a large sum, you are supposed to give it back. But startup investing reverses that expectation. The person who gave the money understood the odds better than the founder did, and was placing a high risk bet, often with other people’s money.

So they say the most important questions are whether the money was spent well, whether the founder acted ethically, and whether they tried their hardest. If the answer is yes, they say, the obligation was met, because the founder was running an experiment.

The problem, they say, is what happens when guilt keeps that experiment running. They have watched founders spend the last year, or even two years, operating a company they no longer believed could work. That drains the founder, traps employees who could be starting companies or doing more useful work, while the investor, who is hedged across many bets, often does not care.

The realization usually comes at the very end, they say, when the investor shrugs and says it is fine. Then the investor asks what the founder will do next, and offers to fund the next company. In their retelling, the founder thinks, “oh wait, I could have been working on my next thing 2 years earlier.”

Questions people ask

Do founders legally have to pay investors back if a startup shuts down?

In a typical venture deal, investors buy a share of the company and lose that money if it fails. There is no legal duty to repay it like a bank loan, unless there was fraud or misuse. That structure is why investors spread small bets across many startups.

Will shutting down hurt a founder’s chance of raising money again?

A shutdown can hurt, because investors look closely at how it was handled. But founders who were honest, careful with cash, and worked hard are often backed again. Investors expect most bets to fail and judge founders on how they spent, communicated, and learned.

What should a founder do instead of keeping a failing company alive?

It can mean cutting costs sooner, telling staff and investors the truth earlier, and stopping work that no longer tests the idea. Any money left after paying bills and wages is usually returned to investors, but the bigger saving is time and energy.

More in Startups