Strong Company Values Always Cut Both Ways
Reid Hoffman taught his chief of staff that honesty at LinkedIn aided introspection but hurt morale, and debate at PayPal sharpened ideas but strained relationships.

Ben Casnocha, the former chief of staff to Reid Hoffman, the LinkedIn co-founder and investor, had heard plenty of talk about corporate values. When Hoffman talked about culture, he dismissed poster words like integrity, excellence, and hard work.
Those are fine to hang in the cafeteria, Hoffman argued, but they do not define how a company actually behaves. Then he gave Casnocha his rule.
“Just as there’s no great opportunity without risk, there’s no decisive culture-shaping value that also doesn’t have drawbacks.”
At LinkedIn in the early days, the defining value was honesty first. There was no forced cheerleading, no talk about destined greatness. When things were not going well, Hoffman and other executives and employees said so openly.
The upside was useful introspection. The whole company could pitch in to solve the biggest problems. The cost was morale, as a number of skilled employees sold shares and departed because they doubted the company’s prospects.
At PayPal, where Hoffman had also worked as an executive, the defining value was, “Let the best idea win.” Every proposal faced sharp questioning. The person who proposed it had to defend it hard and take tough pushback from coworkers.
The upside, Hoffman argued, was analytical rigor, which often yields stronger ideas than deference to tradition or to the chief executive. The downside was a confrontational culture that could stress relationships and undermine collaboration.
It was also, in effect, anti-experience, because even seasoned hires had to re-prove themselves. Hoffman extended the same logic to whether a company decides autocratically or democratically.
He said whether a company tends to run top-down or by group input often shapes daily life inside it, even though companies rarely describe that choice in public. Casnocha wrote that beyond the obvious, he did not believe there are good or bad corporate values, so a job applicant should learn the true culture before joining.
Questions people ask
If everyone knew LinkedIn was struggling, why be so transparent?
Hoffman believed shared knowledge let the entire company collectively problem solve around key challenges, which led to useful introspection. The downside was that some employees sold shares and left because they doubted the future. In his framing, that morale loss came paired with the gain from honesty.
Why would let the best idea win be hard for experienced people?
At PayPal, seniority did not protect an idea from aggressive critique. It was a harder place for experienced hires to operate because they had to re-prove themselves on each proposal. That pressure could improve ideas while making collaboration harder.
How can a job applicant find a company’s real values before joining?
Hoffman’s point was to understand the true culture and its tradeoffs, not the poster list. As general advice beyond the source, that means asking how decisions are actually made and who can overrule whom. Answers there reveal more than any values statement.


