Students Learn What Their Emotions Pay Attention To
When worry centers on test scores, students get skilled at performing for grades, not at the subject.

Andrew Huberman · Essentials: How Emotions & Social Factors Impact Learning | Dr. Mary Helen Immordino-YangA student anxious about an A is still learning, but the lesson is about grades, not the subject. She is learning how to perform for grades.
The reason is simple, says Mary Helen Immordino-Yang, a researcher who studies how emotion shapes learning. Whatever you have emotion about is what you are thinking about, and whatever you are thinking about is what you may learn.
Emotion directs attention to what seems important, and learning follows attention.
If the feelings are about outcomes, the learning is about outcomes. Immordino-Yang gives the questions students ask themselves: "did I get it right? Am I going to flunk?" and "Did I get an A+? I'm so smart, I'm so stupid." When those questions dominate, students get skilled at performing.
In Immordino-Yang's example, a hypothetical student wonders about the physics behind it, asking why a ball rolls down a ramp and whether that relates to why the moon goes around Earth.
The problem, Immordino-Yang argues, is that high stakes testing trains emotion to point at the score. Schools then teach children how to perform, not how to use math and physics to gain a fresh understanding of how things work.
Questions people ask
Do grades always hurt learning?
No. Grades can give useful feedback, but they become a problem when they are the main emotional event. When fear of failing or pride in an A crowds out curiosity about the subject, students rehearse performance rather than ideas.
How can a teacher move emotion from scores to ideas?
By tying facts to a puzzle the student already cares about. A question about why something moves, falls, or works can recruit the same emotional systems as a personal worry, but aim them at understanding. Attention then stays with the idea long enough to learn it.
