KorvaJoin the waitlist
Money

Tax Cuts for Investors Get Sold as Creativity

Writer Tom Frank argues the word's warm glow lets politicians favor capital over work without debate.

AI image
The Tucker Carlson Show · How WWII Doomed “Creativity” and Led to Its Takeover by Silicon Valley and Weapons Companies

Writer Tom Frank says he is not against creativity itself. He is against what he calls its hijacking, to celebrate elites and excuse their privileges.

His shorthand for how the trick works is blunt. “You hear this word and you don’t inquire,” Frank says of creativity and innovation.

That instant approval, he argues, is why the words get attached to the tax cuts for investors that he criticizes.

Frank traces the pattern to Ronald Reagan, who loved the word creativity and titled a late 1960s collection of speeches The Creative Society. When Reagan later pushed big tax cuts, creativity was part of the sales pitch.

The setup came in the 1970s, Frank says. As growth slowed, newspapers warned of an innovation crisis, Congress held hearings, and the Carter administration produced a 300-page report on reviving innovation.

The supply-side answer, a plan to cut taxes to boost investment and output, was simple: cut taxes on capital gains, the profits from selling assets like stocks, to send more money to venture capital, the funds that back young companies. Frank says the 1978 cut did exactly that, and made stocks more attractive, but did not make Americans more innovative.

What it did, Frank says, was “prioritized investment over manufacturing, over making and doing.”

Reagan’s 1981 Kemp-Roth tax cut was then sold explicitly as a way to encourage creativity and escape the doldrums of the 1970s.

For Frank, that is the point. Call a tax cut creativity, and debate stops, while factories move overseas, universities are privatized, and cities are remade for educated elites.

As Frank puts it, “We worship at this shrine,” even as “All the things backfire, but on we go, on and on and on.”

Questions people ask

What is a capital gains tax cut?

Capital gains are profits from selling assets such as stocks or a business. The United States has often taxed them at lower rates than wages, on the theory that lower rates encourage investment and risk taking.

What is venture capital?

Venture capital firms pool money from wealthy individuals and institutions and invest it in young companies in exchange for ownership stakes. The industry grew rapidly after the late 1970s, helped by the 1978 tax cut and a rule change letting pension funds invest in venture funds.

What was the Kemp-Roth tax cut?

It was the 1981 tax law pushed by President Ronald Reagan and sponsored by Representatives Jack Kemp and Senator William Roth. It cut individual income tax rates by about 23 percent over three years and also reduced taxes on estates and business investment.

More in Money