KorvaJoin the waitlist
Money

The Best Win in Congress Is a Hearing That Never Happens

Lawyer Alyssa DaCunha says success means quiet talks with staff, not courtroom victories.

AI image
Original Jurisdiction · The Coming Congressional Investigations Boom: Alyssa DaCunha

A congressional staffer gave lawyer Alyssa DaCunha an ominous preview. Her client, the staffer said, was set to become the committee's featured investigation for the session.

DaCunha is a lawyer at WilmerHale in Washington who guides companies through congressional investigations, formal inquiries by House and Senate committees that can end in televised public hearings.

In that world, she says, the best victory is not a dramatic exchange at the witness table. It is persuading the committee to never call a hearing at all, so the client stays out of the headlines.

Congress does not work like a courtroom, where one side wins and the other loses. DaCunha calls it a do-no-harm exercise, built on negotiation and conversations with staff, and on understanding what members, committees, and party leaders care about.

Success depends less on any single answer than on shaping the setting around a hearing. That means planning communications and government outreach, talking with other lawmakers on the panel, and working on the questions and the opening statement.

The win, she says, is often having no press coverage. It is hard to send around a victory memo when success means nothing happened.

So DaCunha asked for a chance to come in and tell her client's story. She said she understood the larger political concern behind the inquiry, including worries about affordability, but argued the committee did not have the facts right about her client.

Her warning was blunt, DaCunha recalled: "your boss isn't going to have a good day if you hold this hearing." Staff members advise lawmakers on whether a hearing is worthwhile, and no one ever told her she was right.

But her client was never called to testify. Timing can matter too, she said, because the House and Senate have only so many hearing days and must choose which companies to pursue.

Those quiet outcomes are her favorites. She once saw an online commenter write about a client, "well, this guy obviously had a good lawyer," and she counts some of her biggest recent wins as talks that left no public trace because the hearing never happened.

Questions people ask

Who actually decides whether to hold a hearing?

Committee chairs generally make the final call, with input from party leadership. Staff investigators do much of the groundwork, gather documents, interview witnesses, and recommend whether a hearing will help the member make a political or policy point.

Can Congress force a chief executive to testify?

Yes. House and Senate committees can invite witnesses voluntarily, but they can also issue subpoenas that legally require testimony or documents. A witness who refuses can face a contempt citation, followed by referral to the Justice Department or civil action in court.

Why would a committee give up a headline hearing?

Hearings cost time, preparation, and political capital, and committees have limited hearing days. Staff may move on if the facts look shaky, the story is complicated, another target offers a clearer example, or leadership shifts priorities.

More in Money