KorvaJoin the waitlist
Psychology

Duckworth Points to Sober Friendships as a Key Part of AA's Success

Bill W. and Dr. Bob talked all night in Akron, and researchers trace the benefit to a new circle of friends who do not drink.

AI image
Armchair Expert with Dax Shepard · Angela Duckworth #3 (on bringing out your best)

For psychologist Angela Duckworth, the power of Alcoholics Anonymous lies less in willpower or even its famous 12 steps. She points to a change in situation, especially a change in close friends.

The example starts in Akron, Ohio, where stockbroker Bill W. was stuck on a failing business trip. From his hotel lobby, he could hear ice cubes in glasses and laughter from the bar, and he felt the pull to drink.

Instead of trying to resist alone, he telephoned around to find another drinker to talk with. That search led to Dr. Bob, a physician who kept a successful medical practice while drinking heavily.

Dr. Bob's family was doubtful that two drinkers could help each other and gave Bill about 15 minutes. The conversation stretched to something like all night, and that meeting became the start of AA.

Duckworth stresses that the founders were successful people, not weak willed failures. Podcaster Dax Shepard points out that Dr. Bob got through medical school, while Duckworth adds that holding a successful medical practice while drinking into the early morning runs against the weak willed stereotype.

She adds that the book is practically free and widely available, but that is not the magic. Podcaster Dax Shepard makes the same point about his father, who died 28 years sober without ever reading the book but, in his words, "went to a meeting seven days a week" and whose whole friendship group was AA.

Studying AA is hard, Duckworth says, because researchers cannot force one group to attend and forbid another from going. She points to Harvard addiction researcher John Kelly, the first endowed chair in addiction at Harvard, who told her he studied AA because it is the most enduring approach. Duckworth called AA "by far the most enduring and effective treatment," including compared with drug treatments.

Duckworth says there are many ingredients in AA, but research points to one final common path. Members end up with a different social network, with their four closest friends now not drinking, and those emotional ties help carry sobriety.

Duckworth says she would retitle her chapter on peers Join a Group, with the subtitle, "In Other Words, Don't Try to Do This on Your Own." She calls AA an example of how people cannot solve such problems alone.

Questions people ask

Is AA proven to work better than other treatments?

It is hard to prove in the strictest way, because people cannot be forced to attend or stay away. A major 2020 Cochrane review of Twelve-Step Facilitation found it worked about as well as therapies like cognitive behavioral therapy for abstinence, with some advantage in continuous abstinence, and at lower cost. Duckworth presents AA in conversation as among the most effective options, not as a settled winner over every drug treatment.

What actually happens at an AA meeting?

People gather, often in a community room with folding chairs, and take turns sharing experiences with drinking and sobriety. There are no fees or required speeches, and newcomers often get phone numbers and a sponsor, a more experienced member available for one on one calls. Shepard's point about his father captures the routine, showing up daily and building friendships there.

Could a regular group help with something other than drinking?

The episode offers no studies beyond drinking, so the source alone cannot answer that. Duckworth says she has not found a better structure than AA, and wonders where non-addicts would go for the same kind of vulnerable circle. Shepard notes the same model has been applied to behaviors such as overeating, gambling, and sex. Whether the friend circle effect holds outside drinking would need separate evidence.

More in Psychology