KorvaJoin the waitlist
Relationships

Write Down What You Will Accept Before a Hard Talk

After repeatedly taking back a breakup, he found that deciding his bottom line in advance made it possible to follow through.

AI image
Charisma on Command · How To Stand Up For Yourself If You Hate Conflict

Ben, who left a Wall Street and private-equity job to teach confidence and social skills, had a conversation he could not finish. He had been dating a woman for a long time and liked her a lot, but he did not see a future with her and wanted to break up.

Each time he tried, she cried and got very upset, and he caved. He told her he took it back and they should keep dating, because, as he put it, "I didn't want to make her sad for even an instant."

Then he sat down and wrote out three outcomes. His ideal was to "stay friends, keep talking every day, and keep texting every day." He knew that was not what she wanted.

So he defined what else he could live with. An acceptable outcome, he decided, was to end the relationship and feel sad for a short time. The unacceptable outcome was to keep dating someone he did not want to date, and eventually get married, in his words, "because I'm too scared to break up with her."

Writing it down gave him the resolve to go through with the breakup. Hurting someone he cared about was still really hard, but he had already decided it was okay if "we were both hurting for a little bit."

By 2017, he said, they were friends and it was totally fine.

To borrow the method, do it before the meeting, not in it. Write three plain sentences: what you ideally want, what you can accept even if it stings, and what you refuse to accept out of fear or guilt. Bring that bottom line with you, and reread it when your resolve wobbles.

Questions people ask

Why does writing it down help more than just thinking it through?

Ben said writing it down is what gave him conviction to go through with it. He said he does not think he could have done it without getting clear that some shared sadness was acceptable.

How do I figure out what is truly unacceptable?

Ask what future you are afraid of if you cave to avoid discomfort now. Ben framed his as staying with someone he did not want to date, and eventually marrying out of fear. Use that feared future as your unacceptable line.

What if my ideal outcome is unrealistic?

That is normal, and that is why you write all three lines. Naming the ideal helps you aim high, while the acceptable line gives you permission to succeed imperfectly without collapsing into the unacceptable one.

More in Relationships