Korva is a scroll of the internet’s best ideas.
Estonia's chatbot answers with questions
Why Estonia asked
Estonia, a digitally forward country, polled high schoolers and found most were already using commercial ChatGPT and other chatbots. The government then went to OpenAI and requested a product made for Estonian schools, in Estonian, that is Socratic. A student reading Catcher in the Rye in eleventh grade who asks for the plot gets a question about what Holden Caulfield's motivations were, instead of an essay.
The trial
The chatbot is being tried in high schools now, with research from a university in Estonia and from Stanford on usability, uptake, and eventually how it changed learning. Some kids don't want to use it. Some find it ridiculous when a request for how to build a birdhouse comes back as a question about how they think they could build one. A chatbot that only asks questions can't fit every situation.
Limits for children
Estonia will not try it with children under thirteen, and its minister of education holds that schools should not use off-the-shelf chatbots with kids, period. Chatbots for classrooms should be specialized tools designed for schools.
Why do Socratic questions help learning?
The Socratic method takes its name from Socrates, whose questioning of others fills Plato's dialogues. Psychologists have found that producing an answer yourself leaves a stronger memory than reading it, a result called the generation effect. Norman Slamecka and Peter Graf described it in a 1978 study of word recall. Questions that make a student reason through a problem therefore work the same mechanism.
How did Estonia become so digital?
After regaining independence in 1991, Estonia rebuilt its public services around computers rather than paper. Its Tiger Leap program, launched in 1996, put computers and internet connections into schools. In 2001 the country introduced X-Road, a system that lets government databases exchange information securely. In 2005 Estonia became the first country to offer binding online voting in national elections.
Why is thirteen the usual age line?
The United States passed the Children's Online Privacy Protection Act in 1998. It requires parental consent before a website collects personal data from children under 13. Most online services responded by setting thirteen as their minimum age. Thirteen therefore became the common threshold across much of the internet.
More from Fresh Air
