Korva is a scroll of the internet’s best ideas.
Week one
Producer Rick Rubin spent the first week of an album with Neil Young listening to a band that sounded as if it not only couldn't play the songs but never would. Young assured him the next week would be better. Nothing showed Rubin that, but he went along.
Week two
In week two, Young asked drummer Ralph to play the third song again. Ralph pointed out they had already done it, and Young wondered if they could beat it. They tried, and it was no better. Ralph asked to hear the one from the week before, and they turned the bass down and the piano up.
What stayed
The week-one version still had problems and a lot of mistakes, but the feeling was there. What remained was small repair work: ducking a sound here, featuring another there, adding a vocal. Almost the whole album turned out to be recorded that first week, when it seemed like it would never happen.
Why do rough takes sometimes beat polished ones?
A performance recorded with the whole band playing together captures how the players react to each other in real time, and that interplay is hard to rebuild later. Neil Young has long favored this approach. His album Tonight's the Night, recorded in 1973 in loose late-night sessions, was released in 1975 with its rough playing intact. Fixing small errors afterward keeps the original feeling while removing only the distractions.
How do producers repair a recording afterward?
Repair work includes ducking, which lowers the level of a part for a moment so something else can come forward, and overdubbing, which records a new part on top of an existing one. Les Paul popularized overdubbing in the late 1940s, layering his guitar parts on disc recorders and later on tape. Engineers also use balance changes, like turning one instrument up and another down, to change what the listener hears first. Modern digital systems let a producer do all of this on a single track without losing the original.
More from The Diary Of A CEO with Steven Bartlett
