A Canceled Flight Led to a $680 Rental Car
Rental lots hold only so many cars, and a wave of one-way trips can leave them empty and expensive.

Marketplace · This holiday shopping season is all about the dealsNoelle Smith, her husband, and their two children were stuck in Wichita, Kansas, after their return flight to Wyoming was canceled in the FAA ground stop over the weekend that grounded flights. Their backup plan was a flight leaving from Oklahoma City the next day.
"So I immediately ran over to the rental car place at the airport," Smith said.
The agent first said no cars were left. Then, Smith said, the agent offered another car, but for $500.
Smith took it. After fees, the total was $680 for a planned drive of only a few hours.
"I mean, in hindsight, I'm like, well, that's crazy. What just happened?" she said. At the time, the family needed to get home and had work the next day.
That costly scramble shows what happens when grounded airline passengers all look for rental cars at once. Rental lots hold only a limited number of cars, and some companies are still operating with leaner fleets than before the pandemic.
Jonathan Weinberg works with Auto Slash, a company that helps travelers book rental cars. During the disruption, he had to tell some customers, "Sorry, there's literally nothing that we can get you to go from location A to location B."
The industry cut back sharply during COVID, when travel stopped. When demand surged back in 2021, prices reached $200, $300, $400, and $500 a day, Weinberg said, and some travelers turned to U-Haul trucks instead.
Restocking was difficult because new cars were scarce and expensive. Weinberg said, "Rental car companies were actually buying vehicles on the used car market, and that had never happened before."
Some companies never fully rebuilt their fleets to pre-COVID levels. So a sudden wave of one-way trips left them short.
Chris Voronka is an analyst with Deutsche Bank. "It's not like they can bring thousands more cars," he said. "There's a finite supply at any given airport on any given day."
One-way rentals add another problem. Companies did not expect so many one-way trips, and moving those cars back costs money.
Voronka said, "I think for prices to kind of go back to normal, we just need to get the cars back to kind of where they were supposed to be in the first place." Rental prices are expected to jump again around Thanksgiving.
Questions people ask
Why does a one-way rental cost more than returning a car to the same place?
A one-way trip leaves the car in the wrong city for the next renter. The company must eventually pay an employee or a truck to bring it back, or lose revenue while it sits where demand is weaker. That expected cost is added to the renter's price, and it rises when many people all drive the same direction.
Are rental-car fleets still smaller than before the pandemic?
Weinberg says some companies never fully returned to their pre-COVID fleet numbers after downsizing during COVID. Restocking was hard because new cars were scarce and expensive, so a sudden wave of one-way demand can still leave some locations short.



