KorvaJoin the waitlist
Health

A Daughter Could Not Reach Her Father, and a Phone Call Undid Her Mother’s Story

No one but his wife had confirmed seeing him since April 2023, though she said she last saw him in October.

AI image
Bear Brook · A Private Matter, Episode 2

Every time Emily Hickey called her parents' Christmas tree farm in New Hampshire, her mother gave the same answer. Her father, Jay, was napping.

Emily, one of Jay and Patty Hickey's daughters, had watched her father's dementia worsen. She had urged her mother to get a nurse or consider a nursing home, but Patty said Jay wanted neither.

Then Emily sent a text asking to speak to her father one last time, to tell him she loved him and what a good father he had been. Emily said her mother's response to that was like a picture of a plant and a picture of the car in the snow.

Worried, Emily asked her brother John to drive up from New York to check. He found Patty at home and Jay gone. Emily called the Epsom police. It felt, she said, like one of those television shows where everything seems fine but something terrible has happened.

That report on February 26, 2024, began to undo Patty's explanation. Epsom Lt. James Keir knew Jay from earlier welfare calls, when people had found him wandering, and remembered him as very thin and so confused he sometimes seemed unsure who or where he was.

When Keir called Patty, she said Jay was visiting a brother but could not say which one. Jay had three living brothers, in Massachusetts, North Carolina, and Florida. Keir asked her to check.

Early the next morning, Patty said she had left messages. About an hour later, she called back with good news. She said she had confirmed Jay was staying with Donnie in Florida.

Donnie's wife, June Hickey, said that was not true. She said Jay and Donnie had not seen each other in person for years and were not close enough for that kind of visit.

Officers drove to the farm. Patty insisted Jay was in Florida and said she had spoken with him in January, even though he had left his phone behind. She showed them a contact for Donnie, but the number belonged to a different Donald Hickey, whose texts said she had the wrong number.

Keir suggested they call the correct number together. Patty dialed, and June answered. Asked if Jay was with her, June said no. Patty said she did not know where he was, and hung up.

No one besides Patty had been confirmed to have seen Jay since April 2023, about 10 months before Emily's call. Patty said she had last seen him in October.

Just after that April sighting, police found, Patty began canceling Jay's medical appointments and telling doctors, customers, neighbors, and co-workers that he was visiting a brother. In the meantime, she continued to collect his Social Security checks.

After four weeks of investigation, Epsom police Chief Brian Michael brought Patty to the station for another interview. He told her officers had interviewed about 200 people, including everyone on her road twice and all of her children, and warned that as Jay's caretaker she could face legal trouble.

Patty added a new detail. She said she had left Jay at home to check mail at the town offices, two miles away, and found him gone when she returned. She suggested his talk of a brother might have meant a brother who had died.

Michael said he was 99.9 percent sure Jay had walked away from the house and died in the woods, and that her changing accounts made it look as if she had lied. Patty said she could not be certain Jay was dead and did not want to give up hope.

She said she had not reported him missing because she did not think he was missing, and because Jay was private and did not want everyone to know his business. Michael said he did not believe her, and warned police might pursue the matter criminally.

Questions people ask

What does dementia do to a person?

Dementia is a term for a decline in memory, thinking, and daily function that is severe enough to interfere with life. Alzheimer's disease is the most common cause, and symptoms can include confusion, personality changes, and losing the ability to communicate or find familiar places.

Is it common for someone with dementia to wander away?

Yes. Wandering is common, especially as memory and orientation decline, and a person may leave home and be unable to find the way back. Police, caregivers, and doctors often recommend locks, alarms, identification bracelets, and quick searches because exposure and injury are serious risks.

Can family members force an adult with dementia into care?

Generally, an adult can refuse care, even if family members think help is needed. Police and Adult Protective Services can check on someone and offer services, but forcing a nursing home or guardian usually requires a court finding that the person cannot make informed decisions.

More in Health