KorvaJoin the waitlist
Health

One Self-Test Suggests a Coffee-Like Buzz That Fades Sooner

In one commenter's self-test, paraxanthine felt like coffee, peaked quickly, and seemed to wear off sooner, but other early reports were mixed.

AI image
Astral Codex Ten · The Quest For Caffeine You Can Have At Night

Kman, a commenter on the discussion site LessWrong, described wanting an afternoon lift that would still allow sleep at night. In his self-test, summarized by author Scott Alexander, a morning dose felt like a morning cup or two of coffee, while afternoon use still allowed a normal bedtime.

The idea rests on reasoning about how the body handles caffeine and a few anecdotal reports. After coffee, a liver enzyme called CYP1A2 turns caffeine into paraxanthine with a half-life of about five hours, then breaks that second chemical down faster, with around half gone after about three hours. Taking paraxanthine directly would skip the first step and leave only the shorter second step, in theory.

In Kman's account, capsules taken around 4 or 5 p.m. did not keep him from falling asleep at 10 or 11, and even a 7 p.m. capsule left him able to sleep at 11:30. He reported effects peaking within an hour, sometimes in 30 to 45 minutes, and a dip in energy two to three hours after morning doses but not after afternoon or evening doses.

The evidence was still anecdotal and mixed. Paraxanthine had only been sold to consumers for about four years. Commenter Tomas B said it did basically nothing for him even at 200 mg, and a look at two dozen Reddit reviews was about two-thirds positive and one-third negative.

Alexander still favored paraxanthine in his reasoning because about 80 percent of caffeine becomes paraxanthine anyway, so coffee drinkers already carry active levels of it, and because he judged it least likely to interfere with other medicines. Seller Enfinity markets it as cleaner and less jittery. Author Scott Alexander wrote that "You should expect it to last about half as long as the same amount of caffeine," but that remains his expectation, not a settled result.

Questions people ask

Does paraxanthine taste like coffee?

No. In these accounts it came as capsules, not as a brewed drink, so there is no coffee taste or ritual. The reports describe wakefulness and timing, not flavor.

Will it work for everyone?

Not in these reports. Kman's account was positive, Tomas B reported little effect even at higher amounts, and Reddit reviews split about two-thirds positive to one-third negative. The author suggested heavy caffeine tolerance might also mean tolerance to paraxanthine.

What did the author advise about medicines and trying these chemicals?

The explicit ask-your-doctor advice in the cited material was about methylliberine, a different caffeine-like chemical with a shorter half-life. Alexander advised asking a doctor before trying methylliberine if you take medicines and do not know whether they are processed by the same liver enzyme.

More in Health