KorvaJoin the waitlist
Psychology

A Podcast Helped Bring Arrests in a Cold Case, Then Watched Them Fall Apart

The confessed suspect was acquitted, and the man who described burning the body was never charged with her murder.

AI image
The Shawn Ryan Show · #357 Payne Lindsey - “He Was the First Monster I Ever Really Encountered”

Payne Lindsey arrived at the courthouse around noon in a dumb-looking Hawaiian shirt. He had driven down that morning after a friend in local news told him investigators were about to discuss a case they had not publicly discussed in more than a decade.

Within minutes, agents with the Georgia Bureau of Investigation, the state's criminal investigative agency, announced an arrest in the disappearance of Tara Grinstead. They named Ryan Duke, a former student Lindsey had never heard of, and a crowd that had waited years for news asked the obvious question: who was he?

It was the unlikely payoff of an amateur investigation. Lindsey, then a broke freelance filmmaker with no police training, had chosen Grinstead's case for a true crime podcast because it sat atop the state's list of unsolved crimes, and his weekly episodes helped shake loose two arrests before the murder case against Duke collapsed at trial.

Grinstead was a schoolteacher and former beauty pageant winner who vanished in October 2005. Her car sat in her driveway, her front door was locked, her keys and phone were gone, and investigators found a latex glove in her yard.

She lived in a small south Georgia town of about 3,000 people, where everyone knew one another and word traveled fast. Lindsey bought local ads on Instagram to promote the first episode, and neighbors began calling him, arguing with one another, and volunteering tips.

By early 2017, he said, state agents appeared to be following his leads, at one point searching under a house hours after he had crawled through the same space on a tip about a possible body. Then came the February press conference and Duke's arrest on the strength of what Lindsey described as an incoherent, drug-infused account of hitting Grinstead.

Lindsey later learned Duke had been on morphine, Vicodin, and other painkillers during questioning. He argued that a confession alone proves little unless the details line up with evidence, a test he believed investigators had rushed past after 11 years without an answer.

That same day, more than a dozen people told Lindsey to look instead at a man named Bo Dukes. Lindsey interviewed a source around 2 a.m. in a newspaper warehouse, first censoring the name and then publishing it after police arrested Dukes weeks later.

Dukes had come under suspicion after drunkenly telling his girlfriend that he and Ryan Duke had burned Grinstead's body at his uncle's pecan orchard. Through an Army friend of Dukes, Lindsey obtained recordings, messages, and screenshots in which Dukes spoke graphically about watching the fire for hours.

One woman told Lindsey that Dukes had later taken her to that orchard, tied her to a tree during what began as a consensual encounter, and said no one would hear her scream. Lindsey came to call Dukes the first monster he had ever encountered up close.

But Dukes was released on bail within 24 to 48 hours and returned to the podcast's discussion board to describe destroying Grinstead's remains and flirt with female listeners. Duke stayed jailed on a murder charge, while Dukes was never charged with her murder.

At trial, jurors acquitted Duke, rejecting what Lindsey viewed as the same weak account investigators had tested years earlier. A sweeping gag order that Lindsey believed was aimed at quieting the podcast was eventually lifted after outside lawyers challenged it.

Duke cannot be tried again for Grinstead's murder, while Dukes theoretically could face a different case. More than 20 years after Grinstead disappeared, Lindsey says, her family still does not know for certain what happened to her.

Questions people ask

Can Ryan Duke be tried again after being found not guilty?

Double jeopardy generally bars a second trial for the same crime after an acquittal. That protection is why Lindsey says Ryan Duke cannot be charged again with Tara Grinstead's murder, even if investigators develop new theories.

What happened to Bo Dukes?

Lindsey says Dukes was arrested after admitting he helped get rid of Grinstead's body with Ryan Duke. He says Dukes got out on bail within a day or two and was never charged with her murder.

What was the gag order Lindsey describes?

Judges sometimes bar lawyers, witnesses, and others involved in a case from discussing it publicly to protect a fair trial. In this case, the order was unusually broad, drew objections from lawyers across Georgia, and was later removed.

More in Psychology