KorvaJoin the waitlist
Psychology

Wanting Something Can Feel Better Than Having It

Philosopher Peter Rollins says searching and struggling supply their own satisfaction, separate from owning or winning.

AI image
The Minimalists · 563 | Golden Handcuffs

Joshua Fields Millburn, a minimalist writer and co-host, and philosopher Peter Rollins were talking through why long-sought rewards often disappoint when Millburn reached for a hip-hop lyric.

The line, from rapper Belly's 2018 album, was this: "I bought my dream home and I've been having nightmares in it."

Millburn said the line captured exactly what Rollins was describing. Getting the thing you think you want often exposes that it was not the thing you wanted, and he added that this was not an attack on dream homes, pleasure, or even misery.

Rollins said he sees the same pattern in friends who browse homes for sale online. They constantly look at prices and rooms online, he said, and much of the fun is in not having the house yet.

In psychoanalysis, Rollins said pleasure is "a type of liking what you have" and enjoyment is "a type of liking what you don't have." Looking for the house is enjoyment, buying it is pleasure, and a person needs some of both.

Pleasure alone robs pleasure of pleasure, he argued, while enjoyment without ever getting the thing turns into frustration.

His clearest example was sports. Rollins recalled a football team that kept winning when he was a teenager, and said there was so little enjoyment in watching because the outcome was certain. A team that always loses is "a bit rubbish" too, he said, and what people like is the mix of wins and losses and the struggle in between.

Questions people ask

What is the difference between pleasure and enjoyment here?

In this conversation, pleasure means satisfaction from possessing something, like living in a house you bought. Enjoyment means satisfaction from pursuing something you lack, like browsing listings, imagining rooms, and anticipating a move. Rollins argues that people need both, and that possession without pursuit can feel flat.

Does this mean you should never buy your dream home?

No. Millburn said he is not against pleasure, pain, or misery, and does not want to pathologize the dream home. The point is that pleasure alone spoils pleasure, so buying works best alongside the enjoyment of pursuit.

Why would a team that always wins be boring to watch?

Psychologists often link this to uncertainty and anticipation, which can heighten attention and emotion. A guaranteed win removes suspense, while a guaranteed loss removes hope. A close contest keeps both alive, which is why leagues use drafts, salary caps, and schedules to preserve competition.

More in Psychology