KorvaJoin the waitlist
Gaming

A Podcaster Confronted the Man Who Said a Missing Mother Was at His House

The meeting about Crystal Reisinger turned violent within minutes, and Lindsey put it all on tape.

AI image
The Shawn Ryan Show · #357 Payne Lindsey - “He Was the First Monster I Ever Really Encountered”

The man across the patio table tore open a sugar packet, poured it straight into his mouth, and coughed.

Payne Lindsey, the creator of the true crime podcast Up and Vanished, just stared. He had flown to Raleigh, North Carolina, to meet the man face to face, with a camera rolling and a small microphone hidden under his shirt.

The man was known as Catfish John. He had told police that Crystal Reisinger, a young mother from Crestone, Colorado, had spent that evening at his home before she vanished, then took it back. Lindsey believed John was either present when something happened to her or helped dispose of her remains.

Crestone is a remote town of competing religious groups and, Lindsey said, a seedier underbelly. Reisinger had a young daughter and, by Lindsey's account, would never willingly have left her. After Lindsey began covering the case, John started calling him, speaking in what Lindsey described as incoherent, taunting riddles.

In person, the talk turned threatening within minutes. When Lindsey pressed him about what he had told police, John said, "I could reach across the table and just strangle you right now."

Lindsey told him never to threaten him again. John stood up mumbling and walked away, leaving his sunglasses on the table. Lindsey followed to return them and realized John's father was sitting nearby.

Then John picked up a motorcycle helmet and swung it at Lindsey. He missed. Lindsey walked to his car, still shouting at John, and John followed and tried to punch him through the car window.

Lindsey later released the footage. He said it let listeners see, in his words, "who this guy really is." He called John "another monster," who resented being talked about yet relished the attention.

Questions people ask

Who was Crystal Reisinger?

Reisinger was a mother living in Crestone, Colorado, who disappeared. Lindsey said she would never willingly have left her young daughter, and her last reported location was at John's home.

What is Up and Vanished?

Up and Vanished began as Lindsey's low budget attempt to document a cold case in Georgia. The first episode drew about 5,000 downloads in a week, then grew into a major investigative podcast that generated fresh tips from listeners.

Why did the confrontation happen in North Carolina?

John left Crestone after the podcast brought new attention to the case. Lindsey learned he was staying near where he grew up in North Carolina, so Lindsey messaged him to meet and bury the hatchet.

More in Gaming