KorvaJoin the waitlist
Psychology

A Psychologist Doubted More Lab Studies Could Fix The Tenderloin

Inside a San Francisco hotel, researchers discussed prejudice and inequality while people overdosed on the sidewalk outside.

AI image
Experimental History · Incentives are for losers

Adam Mastroianni, a psychologist, came to San Francisco in 2020 for the Society for Personality and Social Psychology's yearly conference. The conference hotel stood in the Tenderloin, and to get inside he and other scholars stepped past people collapsed on the pavement in the grip of suspected overdoses.

Inside, the program listed dozens of talks on stereotyping, prejudice, inequality, and related subjects. Outside, a few feet away, was the kind of suffering those sessions claimed to address.

That short walk shook his confidence that laboratory work would fix what he saw outside. He still believes the barrier to a better world is lack of knowledge, but he doubts the studies presented inside the hotel are the knowledge that will close the gap.

Mastroianni wrote, “I had assumed that the answer to every dilemma was ‘more research’, and that eventually, all of the experiments being presented inside the hotel would solve the problems outside of it.” As he put it, “Something un-clicked for me that day.”

He later called what he saw his Big Horrible Fish, his phrase for an unexamined assumption that would force a person to upend much of life if fully faced. Eating small appetizers in a ballroom near so much misery, he began to wonder whether researchers were trying to make progress or just publishing papers.

The irony made it harder to ignore. Mastroianni wrote, “Scholars were scurrying past homeless people to give talks on social justice,” which he noted echoed a landmark experiment.

He meant the Good Samaritan study by John Darley and Daniel Batson, in which seminary students crossed campus to give a talk and passed a man groaning in a doorway. The students who were told they were late were far less likely to stop, whatever they believed about helping others.

He doubted that running countless more small laboratory studies would ease the suffering on those sidewalks, even if they polished a resume, the document scholars call a CV. He wrote, “I saw many more fish after that, of species varied and grotesque,” meaning more unexamined assumptions of the same kind.

On the rare occasions he enters a conference hotel now, his name badge carries no university affiliation. It simply says guest.

Questions people ask

What does Mastroianni do now?

Mastroianni is a psychologist who studies social behavior and judgment. Since that meeting, he has written about personal conviction and why he thinks reward systems rarely change behavior.

How was the Good Samaritan study actually run?

John Darley and Daniel Batson recruited seminary students to give a short talk, then sent them across campus. Some were told they were late, and those rushed students were much less likely to stop for a man groaning in a doorway.

More in Psychology