Getting 'Not Yet' Instead of Failing Puts You on a Learning Curve
Psychologist Carol Dweck says two small words give students a path forward, while failure suggests they are stuck where they are.

Stanford Alumni · Developing a Growth Mindset with Carol DweckPsychologist Carol Dweck, who studies how children cope with hard problems, opened with a grading policy she had heard about at a Chicago high school.
Students had to pass their courses to graduate, and when they fell short the grade told them they still had work to do to get there.
"Because if you fail you're nowhere but if you get the grade 'not yet' you're on a learning curve," Dweck said. "'Not yet' gave them a path into the future."
Dweck said the phrase stayed with her because it captured what she had seen early in her career, when she gave 10-year-olds problems that were "a little too difficult" for them.
Some reacted in a surprisingly positive way, saying things like, "I love a challenge!" or "I was hoping this would be informative!"
Dweck said those children treated hard work as a way to get more capable, what she calls a growth mindset.
For other children, she said, it was "tragic, catastrophic."
Dweck said children with a fixed mindset felt their intelligence had been "tested and devastated" by the failure.
Without that sense of future progress, Dweck said, they were gripped by what she calls the "tyranny of now."
In Dweck's argument, a failing grade ends the road, while "not yet" says the student can still get there with more time and effort.
Questions people ask
What exactly is a growth mindset?
It is the belief that abilities can grow with effort, good strategies, and help from others. A fixed mindset, by contrast, treats intelligence as a set trait that tests reveal. Dweck argues that the belief itself shapes how people respond to setbacks.
Does just adding the word 'yet' really change how students do?
In the passages cited here, Dweck does not report test results from only adding the word. She offers "not yet" as a way to frame failure, illustrated by the Chicago grade and her work with children facing hard problems. Whether the word alone changes grades is not shown in this source.
Have any schools actually replaced failing grades with 'not yet'?
Dweck cites one Chicago high school that used "not yet." The source does not show other schools using that exact grade. She uses that example to illustrate the mindset idea rather than as a broad policy claim.


