KorvaJoin the waitlist
Money

A Top Fund Can Win With A Software Bet, Not Better Software Picks

HarborVest uses company-level data to separate an industry tilt from true picking skill.

AI image
Dry Powder: The Private Equity Podcast · When Fund Selection Is No Longer Enough w/ HarbourVest’s John Toomey

A private equity fund can land in the top quarter without being a top picker of companies.

John Toomey, who leads investment firm HarborVest, says the difference changes how his firm judges managers.

HarborVest uses company level data in a tool called GP Alpha, which it has used for a long time and has begun making available to large clients. The tool distinguishes between portfolio construction contributing to quartile returns and investment selection.

Toomey describes that approach as the firm's original thesis of staying deeply active across funds, secondaries and direct investments. He says people at the firm share one pot of economics and are encouraged to work together.

The software example shows why the split matters. A fund can present as first quartile, meaning the top quarter of funds started in the same year, because its mix of industries ranked in the top quarter. It held more software than peers among funds from that starting year, and that tilt accounted for its stronger comparative result.

When HarborVest compares that manager's software track record with the software track records of other managers on a contemporaneous basis, the manager turns out to be fundamentally a second quartile software investor. HarborVest uses that unpacking when it is selecting managers.

Toomey says having that company level view, alongside insight into the underlying portfolio, helps the firm make more informed investment decisions about the exposures it wants for investors.

Questions people ask

What is a vintage year in private equity?

A vintage year is the year a fund starts investing. Funds with the same vintage year faced similar prices and economic conditions, so investors compare their returns against each other rather than against funds started much earlier or later.

What is a co-investment?

A co-investment is an investment made directly in a company alongside a fund manager, rather than through the fund itself. Investors often use co-investments to add exposure to particular companies and sometimes to lower overall fees.

Why compare software records on a contemporaneous basis?

It means comparing managers over the same time period. That approach holds market conditions roughly equal, so a software deal completed in 2018 is judged against other software deals from around 2018, not against deals from very different markets.

More in Money