KorvaJoin the waitlist
Science

Alex Murdaugh's Defense Seeks Dismissal Over Disputed Blood Evidence

Lawyers say the lead investigator failed to tell the grand jury about an early lab report finding no human blood on his T-shirt.

AI image
Dateline NBC · Bold request from Alex Murdaugh's defense. Husband accused in sports park murder. Plus, self-defense tips.

Alex Murdaugh, the disgraced South Carolina lawyer convicted in 2023 of killing his wife Maggie and son Paul, is fighting his retrial before it begins.

Earlier this year, the state's top court threw out those verdicts because the clerk had improperly influenced jurors. Prosecutors are preparing to try him again.

At a recent court session ahead of the retrial, his lawyers asked the judge to throw out the new indictments altogether. The defense wants the case restarted from the beginning.

The fight centers on Murdaugh's T-shirt. Lead investigator David Owen, an agent with the South Carolina Law Enforcement Division, told the grand jury in July 2022 that an expert had found high-velocity blood spatter on the shirt, suggesting Murdaugh had been close when the victims were shot. Owen also said Paul's DNA was found in the same area.

The defense says investigators had an earlier state lab report that found no human blood on the shirt, and that the grand jury never heard about it. If there was no blood, the lawyers argued, there could be no blood spatter.

Owen previously testified at trial that he did not learn of that early report until after his grand jury appearance. Prosecutors told the judge there was no error because Owen testified to his best understanding at the time, and their expert still stands by the spatter finding.

Even a win for the defense may only delay the case, since prosecutors could seek a new indictment. The judge has not yet ruled.

Questions people ask

If the indictments are dismissed, does Murdaugh go free?

If a judge dismisses an indictment, the charges are thrown out but prosecutors can usually present the case to a new grand jury. In Murdaugh's case, observers expect prosecutors would seek to re-indict him rather than drop the murder charges.

What does high-velocity blood spatter mean?

High-velocity blood spatter refers to tiny droplets created when blood is struck with great force, such as by a gunshot. Investigators use its size and pattern to estimate how close a person or object was to the bleeding source.

Why were Murdaugh's original convictions overturned?

Juror tampering in this case refers to the state Supreme Court's finding that the court clerk improperly influenced jurors during Murdaugh's 2023 trial. The court overturned his murder convictions on that basis, which is why prosecutors must try him again.

More in Science