KorvaJoin the waitlist
Tech

An AI Ad Can Win on Views and Still Lose the Customer

The real test is not how many people watched, but how many wanted to find the product.

AI image
The Superwall Podcast · Nick Lawton - #1 UGC EXPERT Reveals How To Market Consumer Apps

Nick Lawton, the co-founder of the creator campaign platform Sideshift, was scrolling through TikTok posts for peptide trackers, apps that track peptide use, when he stopped on a telling comparison. One account had posted an AI-made slideshow for a tracking app. Another had posted a rougher video from a real person using the app.

He bases the lesson on what he has seen across hundreds of campaigns. His verdict was blunt. “Great for vanity views, terrible for conversions at the end of the day,” he said of AI-made promos. “I’ve not seen it convert.”

What Lawton meant is that AI-made videos can win on views but lose on sales. He judges a video by a different test. Do people in the comments ask, in his words, “what’s the app,” “what’s this,” and “what’s that”?

That was the difference on the two tracker clips. The AI slideshow had reached 17,900 views, but the comments were suspicious, with people asking what was AI. The real creator video had about 10,000 views, but the comments were asking about the app itself. For Lawton, the smaller video was the winner.

He argues that some marketers mix up views with success, and that mistake can waste a budget. It is possible, he said, to brag about 10 million organic views a month while converting at a tiny fraction of a percent. At that point, he said, a company is just burning money and setting a bad example for the industry.

His point for that peptide tracker account was narrow. Lawton said the account could keep running that AI format, but the smarter move was to keep doubling down on the type of content that was working.

Questions people ask

Why do viewers react differently to AI videos?

Lawton ties it to the two clips he compared. The AI slideshow drew comments like “what the heck is AI,” while the real creator’s video drew questions about the app itself. For him, that difference in the comments is the sign that one video raised suspicion and the other raised interest.

What should a small app maker look for instead of raw views?

Lawton points to comments that ask for the app by name or ask how it works. He also looks for at least one video reaching 10,000 views early on. A video that sparks curiosity about the app is doing the selling job.

What kind of creator video tends to convert better?

Lawton points to a before-and-after from a real person, with a call to action layered at the end. He favors remixing a proven everyday format by 10 to 20 percent, rather than copying it exactly. The call to action should feel like a natural end to the story.

More in Tech