KorvaJoin the waitlist
Psychology

Big Online Fights Stop Being About the Other Side

When groups get large, they stop talking to opponents and obsess over a distorted, enraging stand-in instead.

AI image
CGP Grey · This Video Will Make You Angry

When online groups get big, direct debate fades. Each camp turns inward, trading notes on its outrage at rivals.

That was the warning in a 2015 video from an educator who explained ideas online. He called it one final depressing thought, and put it this way: "When opposing groups get big they don't really argue with each other, they mostly argue with themselves about how angry the other group makes them."

By that, he meant the conversation divided. He argued that online fights could be graphed, and the talk split so each side mostly chatted among itself about the rival side.

In that closed loop, each side turned into a place where claims about the rival multiplied. As with jokes and cat photos, which got copied with a Photoshop tweak here or a changed caption there, the versions that got shared again were the ones that provoked the strongest reaction.

For anger, he argued, the most enraging version spread fastest, not necessarily the most accurate one. That selection pressure built what he called a totem.

"A group almost can't help but construct a totem of the other so enraging they talk about it all the time," he said. Because only the most maddening versions kept getting passed along, the totem was always perfectly maddening.

He closed with a qualification. The gloom did not mean debate was useless, he said. Some arguments still had a point, and some minds were still worth trying to change.

Questions people ask

What exactly is a thought germ?

He treated a thought germ like a germ that lives in brains and reproduces when shared. A joke, photo, or angry claim spreads when one person passes it to another, and it can mutate slightly with each retelling.

Why would anger spread better than other emotions?

He argued that anger bypasses mental defenses and compels sharing. He contrasted that with sadness, which he said does not travel far, and noted that awe also spreads well.

Do online arguments really split into separate groups?

In the video, he argued that they do, saying fights could be graphed to show each side forming a quasi-isolated internet. Those separate clusters mainly shared ideas about the rival, rather than talking directly with it.

More in Psychology