'But Not Americans,' a General Answered When Told People Were Dying in Ukraine
Geopolitical analyst Brandon J. Weichert says younger officers welcomed his warning and senior officers did not.

The Tucker Carlson Show · Trump’s Reaction to the Midterms, the Democrats’ Strategy, and What Happens Next in IranThe panel met at a military facility on the West Coast in March 2022, weeks after Russian forces invaded Ukraine.
Brandon J. Weichert, a geopolitical analyst and civilian consultant from a military family, was one of the experts on stage. He was the only one, he recalled, to raise a yellow flag.
He warned that the war could break NATO, strain the United States, and pull Washington into a forever war. He had just helped his wife's colleague get out of Kherson, in southern Ukraine.
During questions, a two-star general stood up to correct him. “You don't seem to understand what's going on in Ukraine, so let me educate you,” the general said, as Weichert remembered it.
The general said, “We're breaking the Russian army in the field for nothing.” Weichert answered that it was not for nothing, because a lot of people were dying.
The general replied, “But not Americans.”
Four years later, Weichert said he found a similar divide at a base in Georgia in March. Younger and midlevel officers liked what he had to say, he said, while the older colonels and generals did not want to hear it.
“You get stars on your shoulders and you start to think you know it all,” Weichert said.
Questions people ask
What is a two-star general?
A two-star general is a major general in the Army, Air Force, and Marine Corps. The officer wears two stars and typically commands a division of roughly 10,000 to 15,000 troops. It is a senior rank, two steps below a four-star general.
What was happening in Ukraine in March 2022?
Russia launched its full-scale invasion of Ukraine on Feb. 24, 2022. By March, fighting around Kyiv and other cities had driven hundreds of thousands of civilians from their homes. The U.S. and its allies were beginning large weapons shipments to Ukraine.
Why does Kherson come up in this story?
Kherson is a port city on the Dnipro River near the Black Sea, with about 280,000 residents before the war. Russian troops occupied it in the first week of the invasion, making it the first major city they captured. Ukraine retook the city in November 2022 after months of fighting around it.

