One 2025 Writer Called California's Coast Run by 12 Unelected Commissioners
A 2025 account described unchecked power over the coast, a bribery scandal, and a court loss to SpaceX.

welfarecapital.substack.com · Sable Offshore Corp (SOC) - Deep Dive #5In February 2025, a writer studying a stalled offshore oil project called the California Coastal Commission “the single most powerful land-use authority in the US.”
The oil writer described a 12-member panel of unelected commissioners with no term limits. In the words of writer Lloyd Billingsley of Blaze Media, the commission “overrides dozens of elected city and county governments on land use and environmental issues.”
As an example of unchecked power, Billingsley pointed to Commissioner Mark Nathanson, named in the 1980s by Assembly Speaker Willie Brown, who went to prison for shaking down people seeking coastal permits, including Hollywood figures, for bribes.
The oil writer also pointed to SpaceX, which won a lawsuit after the commission tried to block more Falcon 9 launches from Vandenberg Air Force Base. The article does not say when the court ruled. The writer, saying this was only from what he had found, guessed that the opposition reflected Elon Musk becoming active in government, including donations tied to Donald Trump’s campaign.
He offered the court win as proof the commission could be beaten again. The writer says the man who originally spearheaded the commission in the 1970s kept his post for 27 years but does not give the person’s name.
Questions people ask
What does the Coastal Commission actually control?
It has broad final say over building and land use near the coast, including homes, hotels, seawalls, energy projects, and pipeline work. Cities and counties still issue local approvals, but the commission can override them in much of the coastal area.
How do commissioners get their seats if they are unelected?
Six are drawn from the public and six are named by elected officials. They serve fixed four-year staggered terms. Having no term limits is different: it means a commissioner can be reappointed, not that the person serves indefinitely.
Why was SpaceX fighting the commission?
The company sought more frequent Falcon 9 flights from Vandenberg, a military base on the coast, and the commission opposed the increase. The oil writer guessed the opposition reflected Musk’s growing role in government, including campaign donations tied to Donald Trump, cautioning this was only from what he had found.


