KorvaJoin the waitlist
Outdoors

Police Questioned a Wife About Her Missing Husband but Filed No Charges

After hours of questioning about her missing husband, Patty Hickey faced no charges, leaving questions about confusion and responsibility.

AI image
Bear Brook · A Private Matter, Episode 5

Patty Hickey's last extended questioning by police ran more than four hours. Lieutenant Dana Flanders, a New Hampshire officer, pressed her about her missing husband Jay, suggested Jay had walked off to end his life, and then ended the session with no confession and no charges.

Patty had been the focus of the inquiry into Jay's disappearance. Reporter Jason Moon says he kept wondering whether she was too confused to bear responsibility for her actions or whether she chose to do nothing while her husband wandered.

Moon went to hear how Patty sees herself. She was eager to talk, and she recalled meeting Jay in 1980 while she was living temporarily with a friend in New Hampshire after her first marriage ended.

The friend volunteered with the Epsom rescue squad, a local emergency response group. Patty was on the deck when Jay, a fellow volunteer, stopped by to drive her friend to a meeting. She remembers thinking he was a hunk, not large, just striking. He soon asked her for a date, a walk around his farm.

She says she fell in love because he was patient, kind, and nonjudgmental. More than 40 years later, after his dementia diagnosis, she says she still loved him, even as his memory left and returned and then grew worse.

They had fallen in love walking the property. On those same walks, Jay began to stop midway, look around, and ask where they were. Sometimes he looked at her and asked who she was, and she would tell him her name and see relief cross his face.

This summer, Moon and producer Elena Eberwine visited the Christmas tree farm. Patty spent roughly ninety minutes walking them through the house, the fields of trees, and the mountain view, pointing out Jay's work.

According to Moon's account of the walk, she said Jay was brilliant and knew how to do everything, from shaping the trees to clearing choking vines, marking old stumps with flags to protect the mower, and repairing the siding on the house.

Patty lives alone on the farm and handles the upkeep as best she can. She says she avoids sorting through the barn, where Jay's tractor, workbench, worn work gloves, old campaign signs, and a dusty paperback by his co-author remain. Patty says, "I don't know what to do with most of it anyway."

Months after that last interrogation, the town select board, Epsom's elected governing body, met privately with Patty, after which she stepped down as welfare administrator, the local job helping residents in need.

She looked frailer than she had when police questioned her two years before. She also seemed more forgetful than she had during phone calls a few months before the farm visit, losing her train of thought and asking to be reminded of questions.

She tied her scattered thinking in part to Jay's birthday on June 11. Patty said of grief, "It's just a temporary dump."

Jay left for a walk and never returned. Patty says she has concluded he is dead somewhere, but he has not been found, and Moon says he left the farm less interested in pressing her for answers than in wondering whether she was all right alone.

Questions people ask

What is dementia?

Dementia is a loss of memory and thinking that interferes with daily life, and it often worsens over time. In Jay's case, his wife described it as coming and going at first, including not recognizing familiar places or people on their farm walks.

What does keeping up a Christmas tree farm involve?

A Christmas tree farm grows evergreens for several years, shearing them each season to keep a full shape. Owners also clear competing vines, mow between rows, and watch for stumps and pests, steady manual work across many acres.

What is a town select board?

In many New England towns, the select board is the elected body that runs local government. It hires staff, oversees budgets, and handles personnel matters, sometimes in private sessions.

More in Outdoors