KorvaJoin the waitlist
Money

Cheap Index Funds, Left Alone, Beat Most Professionals

Investing is solved with cheap index funds, he says, and the trick is leaving them alone.

AI image
The Diary Of A CEO with Steven Bartlett · Stock Expert: Becoming Rich Is Simple, But You Won’t Do It!

Every few years, Ben Felix, a financial adviser who manages money for a living, sits down with his fiancee to look at her investments. She looks at the login screen and shrugs. She does not remember the password.

It takes the usual round of resets and new passwords to get in. When the account finally opens, Felix says, "Oh, okay, babe, you're rich." She says that is amazing. Then four years pass, they decide to look again, and she has forgotten the password once more.

Felix tells it half as a joke, to make the point about leaving investments alone. He says investing has been solved with low cost index funds, simple baskets that own a little piece of hundreds or thousands of companies so savers get the market's overall return for a tiny fee. The hard part, he says, is sticking with that plan, because psychology gets in the way of long term decisions.

Most professional money managers who try to outdo the market through stock selection and market timing fail to do so. Those who pull ahead for a time tend not to stay ahead, Felix says, and results look worse once fees are subtracted.

Felix says there is no point in trying to beat the market that way. His advice is to buy the market, accept what it delivers over the long run, and then stop fiddling with it.

A famous test of that idea was a 10 year wager by Warren Buffett, the investor known for favoring simple strategies. Buffett bet Ted Seides, a manager who selects hedge funds, private funds that charge high fees to try to beat the market, that a plain fund tracking the S and P 500 would beat any group of hedge funds Seides picked. Buffett won.

The fiancee story is the household version of the same idea. When they finally reset her password and checked, the account turned out to be worth a lot. Felix's follow up is blunt: do not check the app, and, if needed, lose the password.

Questions people ask

What exactly is an index fund?

An index fund is a single fund that owns a little of many companies at once, so it tracks a whole market instead of betting on winners. Because there is almost no trading or stock research involved, the annual fee can be a few hundredths of a percent, compared with 1 percent or more for many active funds.

Why do professional stock pickers usually lose to the market?

Mostly costs, competition, and timing. High fees take a cut every year, thousands of skilled managers trade against each other so an edge quickly disappears, and trying to guess the best moment to buy and sell often means missing the market's best days.

What does research say about checking investments often?

The paper Felix cites found that people who looked more often took less risk and earned lower returns. Felix's explanation is that watching daily ups and downs can be stressful and make the market seem very risky, so people invest less in stocks.

More in Money