Former Biden Official Says China's Lack of One Machine Is Among the Biggest Forces in Chips
The official who oversaw $39 billion in factory incentives says denial of Dutch-built equipment shapes competition.

The Lawfare Podcast · Lawfare Daily: Mike Schmidt Talks CHIPS and U.S. Industrial PolicyIn the view of Mike Schmidt, the former Commerce Department official who ran the office that turned the 2022 CHIPS Act into factory deals, China's lack of access to EUV technology is arguably the development that most shapes the global chip industry.
Schmidt said, "arguably the most important structural shaper of the global semiconductor industry right now is the fact that China does not have access to EUV technology."
EUV means extreme ultraviolet, and the machines are the superprecise tools that print the tiniest circuits onto silicon. They are built by ASML, a Dutch company, and they are essential for making leading edge processors.
Without those machines, Chinese firms cannot easily make the most advanced chips at scale. That absence shapes who can compete at the frontier. At the time, Schmidt's office had $39 billion to help pay for plants in the United States.
Schmidt sketched what would change if that denial ended. If Huawei, the Chinese electronics maker, could buy EUV machines from ASML, it could churn out capable five nanometer chips, a dense and powerful category used for top phones and AI systems.
In that world, he said, American backed makers such as Samsung and Intel would face a stronger Chinese rival. TSMC and Intel would also compete with Huawei and others for each new machine ASML can build.
The twist is that Washington did not officially describe the denial as industrial policy. Schmidt noted that he was not involved in export controls when he was in government, but said the Biden administration was careful and consistent in saying export controls were a tool for other national security concerns, not industrial policy.
Schmidt said that distinction deserves scrutiny and should be revisited. Even if the intent behind the export controls was not industrial policy, he said, the effect was.
He recalled negotiating a subsidy with one chip company that had a pending matter before the Bureau of Industry and Security, the Commerce unit that handles export controls. Tying the two together might have made getting what he wanted easier, but agency lawyers discouraged it.
With limited funds, officials also decided not to try to bring ASML production to the United States. Schmidt said they were comfortable leaving production in an allied country, the Netherlands, and focusing American capital elsewhere.
Questions people ask
Why can't China simply build its own EUV machine?
Each system combines lasers, optics, and precision controls from thousands of suppliers across the United States, Germany, Japan, and the Netherlands. The mirrors must be nearly perfect at the atomic scale, and U.S. and Dutch rules block key parts and know-how from going to China.
What is a five-nanometer chip?
It is an industry label for a generation of very dense chips that pack more transistors into less space. That density generally brings more speed and efficiency, which matters for high-end phones and AI systems.
What is the Bureau of Industry and Security?
It is the Commerce Department agency that decides which sensitive American technologies can be sold abroad. It maintains restricted product lists and company lists, including rules limiting sales of advanced chips and chipmaking tools to China.


