Fall in Love With the Customer’s Problem, Not Your Solution
A Harvard professor says testing a chosen answer is science in reverse.

productmasterynow.com · 617: Test your gut, don’t trust it –the scientific mindset for product teams – with Stefan Thomke, PhD – Product Mastery NowHarvard Business School professor Stefan Thomke was explaining the difference between a skeptic and a denialist when he turned the lesson on product teams. One seeks the truth, and the other defends a conclusion.
His advice to managers was direct: “Fall in love with the customer’s problem, not your solution.”
By skeptic, Thomke means someone who stays neutral. He puts it this way: “They look at the evidence with an open mind and want the truth.” By denialist, he means: “A denialist starts with a conclusion, picks evidence that supports it, and dismisses evidence that contradicts it.”
Product managers slip into the second camp, he says: “Product managers do this when they run customer research to validate a solution instead of finding unmet needs.” They have already chosen the answer, and the interviews and surveys become a way to justify it.
Thomke calls that “running the scientific method in reverse.” He says, “It’s easy to fall in love with a conclusion and only question the evidence that disagrees with us.”
To fall in love with the problem, in his view, is to stay neutral about the answer until the evidence points the way. That means using research to find unmet needs rather than to defend a chosen solution.
That discipline is what he means by “Create an experimentation culture, a shared scientific mindset.” It is not simply doing more research, but being willing to let hard evidence overturn a favored solution.
Questions people ask
How can a team tell if it is validating rather than discovering?
Look at what would change your mind. If the research is designed so a negative result would cause you to drop or rethink the solution, you are discovering. If every result can be read as support for going ahead, you are validating.
What does falling in love with the problem look like in practice?
Spend time on the need before debating fixes. Watch what customers do, ask what is still hard or annoying, and write down the problem in their terms. Then treat any proposed solution as one guess to be tested against that problem.
Does this mean product intuition has no place?
No, but Thomke argues it should be tested. Intuition and experience are useful for forming ideas about what customers need and what might work. Experiments and customer evidence then check whether those hunches hold up.

