KorvaJoin the waitlist
Psychology

Former Massachusetts Officer Found Guilty of Killing Sandra Birchmore

Jurors accepted prosecutors' claim that he killed the pregnant young woman to hide a relationship that began when she was underage.

AI image
Dateline NBC · Verdict in Sandra Birchmore murder trial. A husband's stunning admission. Plus, Flock cameras.

On Tuesday, a federal jury found former Massachusetts police officer Matthew Farwell guilty on all charges in the 2021 killing of Sandra Birchmore, a day after jurors reported they were deadlocked.

Prosecutors argued that Farwell killed Birchmore to keep her from revealing a sexual relationship that, in their account, started when she was underage and taking part in a youth mentorship program run by local police.

They told jurors that Birchmore was pregnant, that Farwell believed the child was his, and that he had lost control of her as she threatened to reveal the relationship.

A central piece of evidence was lobby video from Birchmore's apartment building. Prosecutors replayed it in closing arguments, showing Farwell arriving around 9:14 p.m. wearing a mask with his hood up, then leaving after under 30 minutes.

Prosecutors tied that departure to data from Birchmore's phone, which stopped recording steps around the same time, and argued that was when she died. The defense argued that Birchmore died by suicide after Farwell ended their relationship.

The verdict drew loud gasps in the courtroom. Birchmore's cousin Barbara Wright was visibly shaken and crying, and later described nearly six years of waiting as sadness, happiness, and relief.

Farwell will be sentenced on February 3, when he faces mandatory life in prison.

Questions people ask

What is a police explorer program?

It is a youth program run with local police departments that introduces teenagers to law enforcement work through mentoring, training, and ride-alongs. Participants are minors, and adult officers serve as advisers, which gives them authority and regular access to the young people.

Was Birchmore's death always treated as a murder?

No. Her death in February 2021 was first ruled a suicide by the local medical examiner. The ruling was later changed to undetermined, and federal investigators continued to pursue the case until Farwell was charged.

What happens next for Farwell?

A judge will formally impose punishment at a separate hearing, now set for February 3. Prosecutors said Farwell faces mandatory life in prison, meaning the judge will have no option for a lighter sentence on the main count.

More in Psychology