KorvaJoin the waitlist
Psychology

There Is No Single Fingerprint for Anger, Fear, or Happiness

After faces, bodies, and brains all failed to yield a single signature, she concluded emotions are remade each time.

AI image
The Knowledge Project · #92 Lisa Feldman Barrett: Balancing the Brain Budget

Lisa Feldman Barrett, a neuroscientist who studies emotion, began by studying how people see themselves. The measures she was using to track feelings were not behaving as expected, so she decided to stop asking people how they felt and measure emotion objectively instead.

The textbooks seemed clear. Everyone scowls in anger, smiles in happiness, and pouts in sadness, and everyone recognizes those faces. Barrett set out to learn to read them.

Then she read past the claims and into the data. The idea that a scowl everywhere means anger, and that everyone recognizes it that way, was not what the studies actually showed. There was no facial signature she could rely on.

She turned to the body, where the common wisdom was just as neat: blood pressure rises and the face flushes in anger, while the heart races in fear. Again, she said, the supposed one-to-one patterns fell apart when she examined the evidence.

Next she looked to the brain, where many expected to find one built-in circuit for fear, one for anger, and one for sadness, shared by all people and perhaps some animals. What was emerging from brain imaging looked much like what she had found in the face and the body.

Barrett said, "there is no universal physical signature for any emotion that's ever been studied." That left a puzzle, because people plainly feel emotions.

As Barrett put it, emotions "feel like they happen to you, like they hijack you and take you over." She said that sense of being taken over is what made the missing signature a mystery.

Speaking in 2020, she said she had abandoned her earlier work and completely switched her research program over that question. By then, she said, she was almost 30 years into pursuing it.

Her answer rejects the familiar package theory, the idea that anger or fear always arrives as a coordinated set of thoughts, feelings, facial movements, and bodily changes. Instead, she compares emotion to thinking or remembering: the brain is making sense of the immediate moment, just using different information each time.

Questions people ask

Can a brain scan tell whether someone is angry?

No. Brain imaging can find statistical patterns linked to emotion words, but the patterns vary widely from person to person and occasion to occasion. There is no single circuit that always means anger or fear, so a scan alone cannot diagnose what someone feels.

If emotions are constructed, why do they feel uncontrollable?

They feel automatic because the brain works quickly and outside awareness to interpret bodily signals and surroundings. By the time the result reaches consciousness, it arrives as a feeling that seems to have happened to you.

Does culture change how emotion works, or just how we talk about it?

Barrett argues that learning wires the brain, so culture and experience shape how bodily signals get interpreted. Words and concepts learned in childhood help the brain predict what is happening and what to do next.

More in Psychology