Why Subscription Software Was Worth More Than Another Annual Fee
Customers paid vendors to operate the software, while vendors gained an ongoing stream of payments.

Invest Like the Best with Patrick O'Shaughnessy · Eric Vishria – The Past, Present, and Future of SaaS and Software - [Invest Like the Best, EP.183]Software companies collected annual fees long before subscriptions became common. Customers paid a large sum to buy a program, then paid for maintenance and upgrades each year. Why would replacing that arrangement with a subscription make the business more valuable?
Eric Vishria, a venture capitalist who invests in software companies, argued in a 2020 interview that the change benefited both vendors and customers.
For customers, buying software also meant taking responsibility for operating it. They needed computers to run it on and people to handle installation, maintenance, and upgrades. A subscription transferred much of that work to the vendor, allowing the customer to concentrate on its own business.
For vendors, the annual payment became the continuing price of using the software. Under the older arrangement, the large software payment arrived at purchase, followed by smaller maintenance charges. Under a subscription, customers kept paying for access, with annual fees that could grow over time.
That does not make every subscription more profitable than an upfront sale. Prices, operating costs, and how long customers stay all matter. Vishria’s argument was that an ongoing stream of payments, combined with software’s high profit margins, could become especially valuable as the business grew.
Taking over operations also created opportunities to work more efficiently. A company running software for thousands of customers could justify investing in automation that would be difficult for each customer to develop separately.
Those advantages did not require an entirely unfamiliar product. Experienced software founders could return to problems they already understood. Dave Duffield, who founded PeopleSoft, later co-founded Workday, which delivered finance and human resources software through the cloud.
The customer still needed to manage payroll or keep the accounts. The subscription let it pay another company to keep the underlying software running, too.
Questions people ask
What is the difference between single-instance and multi-tenant software?
Single-instance means the vendor sets up and runs a separate copy of the software for each customer. Multi-tenant means many customers share the same copy and underlying system, with their data kept separate, which is usually cheaper to operate and can be updated all at once.
Why is recurring revenue considered more valuable than a one-time sale?
Investors prize recurring revenue because it is predictable, renews each year, and can expand as customers add users. Vendors also like it because customer payments fund ongoing support and improvement, rather than depending on finding the next one-time sale.
What do Salesforce, Workday, and ServiceNow actually sell?
Salesforce mainly sells customer relationship software for tracking sales and service. Workday sells software for human resources and finance, such as payroll and planning. ServiceNow sells software for managing technology requests and workflows inside large organizations.


