KorvaJoin the waitlist
Money

Free Returns Win Shoppers, but Stores Are Adding Fees to Afford Them

Preparing a product for resale can cost up to 40% of its price, so long holiday windows often come with restocking fees, postage, and loyalty-program catches.

AI image
qz.com · Holiday return deadlines at 7 retailers: fees, exclusions and cutoffs

About 81% of shoppers check a store's return policy before buying, and 82% say free returns matter. Long return deadlines have become a way for stores to compete for those shoppers.

The competition is expensive. Figures from the National Retail Federation, cited in CNBC reporting, had projected 2025 merchandise returns at $849.9 billion. Making a used item salable again can run as high as 40% of its original price, according to Iowa State supply chain management professor Robert Overstreet.

Many stores have responded by keeping the calendar generous but making the conditions stricter. In 2023, 81% of U.S. retailers charged shoppers in some way to send purchases back. Among merchants that added a return charge, 47% later heard more complaints from customers.

Best Buy showed the tradeoff during the 2025 holiday season. Purchases dated Oct. 31 to Dec. 31, 2025 were returnable until Jan. 15, 2026, earlier than the Jan. 31, 2026 date offered by several rivals. Opened electronics carried a 15% restocking fee, and devices requiring activation carried a flat $45 fee.

Shipping was the exception at Best Buy, which typically included a prepaid return label. The pattern was different at Macy's, where purchases dated Oct. 6 to Dec. 31, 2025 qualified until Jan. 31, 2026, based on the purchase date.

A Macy's return sent by mail cost $9.99. Shoppers enrolled in its free Star Rewards loyalty program sent mailed returns without a charge. Kohl's offered a similar long window, with most items bought Oct. 5 to Dec. 31, 2025 returnable until Jan. 31, 2026.

That extension included high-end electronics, watches and mattresses that normally have only 30 days. Returns handed over inside Kohl's were free, while mailed returns required the shopper to pay postage. Original shipping charges generally were not refunded.

Questions people ask

What is a restocking fee?

A restocking fee is a portion of the price that a store keeps when an item comes back. At Best Buy during the holiday period described, the fee was 15% for opened electronics and a flat $45 for devices that need activation.

Why does getting a return ready to resell cost so much?

A returned item often must be inspected, repackaged, tested, and shipped again before it can be resold. Electronics can require extra testing once the box has been opened, and some items can only be marked down or discarded.

Why do stores keep long holiday windows if returns are so costly?

Return terms influence where people choose to shop, with about 81% checking the policy before buying. A long deadline can attract holiday buyers even if fees, receipts, packaging rules, and category exclusions limit how the return works.

More in Money